Schulze Zacharias Joel, Schubert Franziska, Gernhardt Christian Ralf, Krayl Nele, Peters Anna, Unverzagt Susanne, Wagner Karoline, Wienke Andreas, Führer Amand
Institute for Medical Epidemiology, Biometrics and Informatics, Interdisciplinary Center for Health Sciences, Medical School of the Martin Luther University Halle-Wittenberg, Halle (Saale), Germany.
University Outpatient Clinic for Conservative Dentistry and Periodontology, Department of Dentistry, Martin Luther University Halle-Wittenberg, Halle (Saale), Germany.
J Urban Health. 2025 Feb;102(1):125-138. doi: 10.1007/s11524-024-00916-1. Epub 2024 Oct 8.
The WHO emphasizes the importance of taking area-level factors into account when formulating public health interventions. The aim of this systematic review was to identify which area-level factors are associated with children's dental caries in Europe and might therefore be a suitable starting point for public health interventions. We conducted a systematic review based on a search in PubMed, Web of Science, and Cochrane Library including all European studies on caries in children and their area-level factors published since the year 2000 in English or German. We included 39 studies and identified 13 area-level factors investigated in the literature: degree of urbanization, deprivation, mean housing price, gross-national product, mean level of education, unemployment proportion and income, density of supermarkets, snack bars and dental offices, health, diet, and crime. Rural residency and higher unemployment were weakly associated with poorer oral health regarding dental caries. Deprivation showed a stronger (inverse) association. For income, findings were ambiguous; studies showed associations in both directions. For the other determinants, the included studies found no association. Many studies reported associations between place of residence and children's dental caries, but the mediators on this causal path are still not clearly established. The area-level factors analyzed in this review seem to play a role, but more studies with designs that allow causal interpretation of findings are needed to establish solid robust evidence that can be used in the formulation of future health policies.
世界卫生组织强调在制定公共卫生干预措施时考虑地区层面因素的重要性。本系统综述的目的是确定哪些地区层面因素与欧洲儿童龋齿相关,因此可能是公共卫生干预措施的合适切入点。我们基于在PubMed、科学网和考科蓝图书馆的检索进行了一项系统综述,纳入自2000年以来以英文或德文发表的所有关于儿童龋齿及其地区层面因素的欧洲研究。我们纳入了39项研究,并确定了文献中调查的13个地区层面因素:城市化程度、贫困程度、平均房价、国民生产总值、平均教育水平、失业率和收入、超市、小吃店和牙科诊所的密度、健康状况、饮食和犯罪率。农村居住和较高的失业率与龋齿方面较差的口腔健康呈弱关联。贫困显示出更强的(反向)关联。对于收入,研究结果不明确;研究显示了两个方向的关联。对于其他决定因素,纳入的研究未发现关联。许多研究报告了居住地与儿童龋齿之间的关联,但这条因果路径上的中介因素仍未明确确立。本综述中分析的地区层面因素似乎发挥了作用,但需要更多采用能对研究结果进行因果解释设计的研究,以建立可用于制定未来卫生政策的可靠有力证据。