Gain- and loss-of-function alleles within signaling pathways lead to phenotypic diversity among individuals.

Understanding how phenotypic diversity is generated is an important question in biology. We explored phenotypic diversity among wild yeast isolates () and found variation in the activity of MAPK signaling pathways as a contributing mechanism. To uncover the genetic basis of this mechanism, we identified 1957 SNPs in 62 candidate genes encoding signaling proteins from a MAPK signaling module within a large collection of yeast (>1500 individuals). Follow-up testing identified functionally relevant variants in key signaling proteins. Loss-of-function (LOF) alleles in a PAK kinase impacted protein stability and pathway specificity decreasing filamentous growth and mating phenotypes. In contrast, gain-of-function (GOF) alleles in G-proteins that were hyperactivating induced filamentous growth. Similar amino acid substitutions in G-proteins were identified in metazoans that in some cases were fixed in multicellular lineages including humans, suggesting hyperactivating GOF alleles may play roles in generating phenotypic diversity across eukaryotes. A mucin signaler that regulates MAPK activity was also found to contain a prevalance of presumed GOF alleles amoung individuals based on changes in mucin repeat numbers. Thus, genetic variation in signaling pathways may act as a reservoir for generating phenotypic diversity across eukaryotes.