Centre of Research on Families and Relationships, The University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, UK.
Usher Institute, The University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, UK.
Cleft Palate Craniofac J. 2024 Oct;61(10):1713-1720. doi: 10.1177/10556656231183386. Epub 2023 Jun 25.
Given prior craniofacial research reporting higher risk for negative social interactions, this study aimed to explore experiences of stigma described by children with cleft lip and/or palate (CL/P).
Qualitative interviews were conducted with children in three sessions (totaling 90-180 min) using creative activities in their homes and/or and walking interviews in their neighborhood. Interview transcriptions were interpreted primarily with thematic analysis following theoretical frameworks of the stigmatization process and self-stigma concept.
Participants were recruited through Operation Smile Colombia. Interviews took place at children's homes and neighborhoods within three Colombian regions (Boyacá, Bogotá and Cundinamarca).
Children (N = 12) with CL/P aged between 6-12 years were interviewed.
Themes fit within the stigmatization process, starting with labeling and stereotyping, such as a range of mockery, and group separation by peers highlighting their not belonging and being socially 'other'. Status loss themes included negative appraisals of cleft-related differences and being perceived as 'ill' and 'imperfect'. Social exclusion themes reflected limited social interactions and loneliness. Self-stigma themes included shame about speaking with peers and anticipation of negative social interactions.
The study results suggest that the process of stigmatization and self-stigma adversely affect social interactions for children with a cleft in multiple ways. Healthcare practitioners and policy makers can help address the potential consequences of stigma by implementing interventions at micro, meso and macro levels.
鉴于先前的颅面研究报告称,唇腭裂(CL/P)儿童的负面社交互动风险更高,本研究旨在探讨唇腭裂儿童所描述的耻辱经历。
采用创意活动在家庭中以及在社区中进行行走访谈,对 12 名 6-12 岁的唇腭裂儿童进行了三次共 90-180 分钟的定性访谈。访谈记录的解释主要采用理论框架下的主题分析法,包括污名化过程和自我污名概念。
参与者是通过微笑行动哥伦比亚分会招募的。访谈在哥伦比亚三个地区(博亚卡、波哥大和昆迪纳马卡)的儿童家庭和社区中进行。
有 CL/P 的儿童(N=12)接受了采访。
主题符合污名化过程,从标签和刻板印象开始,例如各种嘲笑,以及同龄人将他们分开,突出他们不属于群体,是社会上的“异类”。地位丧失的主题包括对与腭裂相关的差异的负面评价,以及被视为“病态”和“不完美”。社会排斥的主题反映了有限的社会互动和孤独感。自我污名化的主题包括与同龄人说话的羞耻感和对负面社交互动的预期。
研究结果表明,污名化和自我污名化过程以多种方式对唇腭裂儿童的社交互动产生不利影响。医疗保健从业者和政策制定者可以通过在微观、中观和宏观层面实施干预措施,帮助解决污名化的潜在后果。