D'Urso Shannon, Wootton Robyn E, Ask Helga, Brito Nunes Caroline, Andreassen Ole A, Hwang Liang-Dar, Moen Gunn-Helen, Evans David M, Havdahl Alexandra
Institute for Molecular Bioscience, The University of Queensland, Brisbane, Queensland, Australia.
The University of Queensland, Brisbane, Queensland, Australia.
Psychol Med. 2024 Oct 9;54(12):1-14. doi: 10.1017/S0033291724002216.
Previous observational epidemiological studies have suggested that coffee consumption during pregnancy may affect fetal neurodevelopment. However, results are inconsistent and may represent correlational rather than causal relationships. The present study investigated whether maternal coffee consumption was observationally associated and causally related to offspring childhood neurodevelopmental difficulties (NDs) in the Norwegian Mother, Father and Child Cohort Study.
The observational relationships between maternal/paternal coffee consumption (before and during pregnancy) and offspring NDs were assessed using linear regression analyses ( = 58694 mother-child duos; = 22 576 father-child duos). To investigate potential causal relationships, individual-level ( = 46 245 mother-child duos) and two-sample Mendelian randomization (MR) analyses were conducted using genetic variants previously associated with coffee consumption as instrumental variables.
We observed positive associations between maternal coffee consumption and offspring difficulties with social-communication/behavioral flexibility, and inattention/hyperactive-impulsive behavior (multiple testing corrected < 0.005). Paternal coffee consumption (negative control) was not observationally associated with the outcomes. After adjusting for potential confounders (smoking, alcohol, education and income), the maternal associations attenuated to the null. MR analyses suggested that increased maternal coffee consumption was causally associated with social-communication difficulties (individual-level: beta = 0.128, se = 0.043, = 0.003; two-sample: beta = 0.348, se = 0.141, = 0.010). However, individual-level MR analyses that modelled potential pleiotropic pathways found the effect diminished (beta = 0.088, se = 0.049, = 0.071). Individual-level MR analyses yielded similar estimates (heterogeneity = 0.619) for the causal effect of coffee consumption on social communication difficulties in maternal coffee consumers (beta = 0.153, se = 0.071, = 0.032) and non-consumers (beta = 0.107, se = 0.134, = 0.424).
Together, our results provide little evidence for a causal effect of maternal coffee consumption on offspring NDs.
以往的观察性流行病学研究表明,孕期喝咖啡可能会影响胎儿神经发育。然而,研究结果并不一致,可能代表的是相关性而非因果关系。在挪威母婴队列研究中,本研究调查了母亲孕期喝咖啡与后代儿童神经发育困难(NDs)之间是否存在观察性关联及因果关系。
采用线性回归分析评估母亲/父亲孕期及孕前喝咖啡与后代NDs之间的观察性关联(母婴二人组n = 58694;父子二人组n = 22576)。为研究潜在的因果关系,使用先前与咖啡消费相关的基因变异作为工具变量,进行个体水平分析(母婴二人组n = 46245)和两样本孟德尔随机化(MR)分析。
我们观察到母亲喝咖啡与后代社交沟通/行为灵活性困难以及注意力不集中/多动冲动行为之间存在正相关(多重检验校正P < 0.005)。父亲喝咖啡(阴性对照)与这些结果无观察性关联。在调整潜在混杂因素(吸烟、饮酒、教育程度和收入)后,母亲喝咖啡与后代NDs之间的关联减弱至无统计学意义。MR分析表明,母亲咖啡摄入量增加与社交沟通困难存在因果关联(个体水平:β = 0.128,标准误 = 0.043,P = 0.003;两样本:β = 0.348,标准误 = 0.141,P = 0.010)。然而,对潜在多效性途径进行建模的个体水平MR分析发现,这种效应减弱(β = 0.088,标准误 = 0.049,P = 0.071)。个体水平MR分析对母亲咖啡消费者(β = 0.153,标准误 = 0.071,P = 0.032)和非消费者(β = 0.107,标准误 = 0.134,P = 0.424)咖啡消费对社交沟通困难的因果效应得出了相似的估计值(异质性I² = 0.619)。
总之,我们的研究结果几乎没有为母亲喝咖啡对后代NDs的因果效应提供证据。