Marlow Laura, Drysdale Hannah, Waller Jo
Centre for Cancer Screening, Prevention and Early Diagnosis, Wolfson Institute of Population Health, Queen Mary University of London, London, UK.
School of Cancer and Pharmaceutical Sciences, King's College London, London, UK.
J Med Screen. 2025 Jun;32(2):93-99. doi: 10.1177/09691413241283356. Epub 2024 Oct 9.
ObjectivesPrimary human papillomavirus (HPV) testing in cervical screening offers the opportunity for women to be given a choice between HPV self-sampling and traditional clinician screening. This study assessed attitudes towards a choice and anticipated future preference among women who had collected a vaginal self-sample alongside their usual cervical screen.SettingThirty-eight general practices across five areas in England.MethodsOverall, 2323 women (24-65 years; response rate: 48%) completed a survey after collecting a self-sample and having a clinician screen at their GP practice. We asked which test they preferred and assessed attitudes to being offered a choice. We explored age, education, ethnicity and screening experience as predictors of attitudes towards a choice and anticipated future choice.ResultsMost participants felt they would like a choice between self-sampling and clinician screening (85%) and thought this would improve screening for them (72%). However, 23% felt it would be difficult to choose, 15% would worry about making a choice, and nearly half would prefer a recommendation (48%). Compared with women with degree-level education, those with fewer qualifications were more likely to say they would worry about having a choice or would not want a choice (p < 0.001). The majority said they would choose to self-sample at home if offered a choice in the future (69%; n = 1602/2320).ConclusionsSelf-sampling is likely to be popular, but offering a choice could cause worry for some people and many would prefer a recommendation. Supporting people to make a choice will be important, particularly for those with lower levels of education.
目标
在子宫颈癌筛查中进行原发性人乳头瘤病毒(HPV)检测,为女性提供了在HPV自我采样和传统临床医生筛查之间做出选择的机会。本研究评估了在进行常规子宫颈筛查时采集过阴道自我样本的女性对这种选择的态度以及对未来偏好的预期。
设置
英格兰五个地区的38家普通诊所。
方法
总体而言,2323名女性(24 - 65岁;回复率:48%)在其全科医生诊所采集自我样本并接受临床医生筛查后完成了一项调查。我们询问了她们更喜欢哪种检测方法,并评估了对提供选择的态度。我们探讨了年龄、教育程度、种族和筛查经历作为对选择态度和预期未来选择的预测因素。
结果
大多数参与者认为她们希望在自我采样和临床医生筛查之间做出选择(85%),并认为这会改善她们的筛查体验(72%)。然而,23%的人觉得难以选择,15%的人会担心做出选择,近一半的人更希望得到推荐(48%)。与受过大学教育的女性相比,学历较低的女性更有可能表示她们会担心有选择或不想要选择(p < 0.001)。大多数人表示,如果未来有选择,她们会选择在家中进行自我采样(69%;n = 1602/2320)。
结论
自我采样可能会很受欢迎,但提供选择可能会让一些人感到担忧,而且许多人更希望得到推荐。支持人们做出选择将很重要,特别是对于教育程度较低的人。