Department of Anaesthesiology, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, Bathinda, Punjab, India.
Department of Community and Family Medicine, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, Bathinda, Punjab, India.
BMC Palliat Care. 2024 Oct 9;23(1):240. doi: 10.1186/s12904-024-01572-7.
This paper aimed to explore the palliative care (PC) needs and barriers to access among cancer patients in a rural region of North India with a high cancer burden.
A Participatory action research (PAR) approach was employed. Situational assessment, community sensitization workshops (CSWs) and door-to-door surveys were planned, conducted and developed over three PAR cycles. A parallel convergent mixed-methods approach was adopted wherein the quantitative data from door-to-door surveys and qualitative data from CSWs and investigator field notes were collected and analyzed to provide a comprehensive understanding of PC needs and barriers to access. Descriptive statistics and thematic analysis were used.
A total of 27 CSWs involving 526 stakeholders were conducted. A total of 256 cancer patients were assessed for PC needs and symptom burden using the Supportive and Palliative Care Indicators (SPICT-4ALL) and the Edmonton Symptom Assessment System (ESAS) tool, respectively. Based on the SPICT assessment, all patients (n = 256) satisfied general and/or cancer-specific indicators for PC. The majority (56.6%) had ≥ one moderate-severe symptom, with the most common symptoms being tiredness, pain and loss of appetite. Analysis of qualitative findings generated three themes: unmet needs, burden of caregiving, and barriers and challenges. Cancer affected all domains of patients' and their families' lives, contributing to biopsychosocial suffering. Social stigma, discrimination, sympathizing attitudes and lack of emotional and material support contributed to psychosocial suffering among cancer patients and their caregivers. Lack of awareness, nearby healthcare facilities, transportation, essential medicines, trained manpower and education in PC, collusion, fear of social discrimination, faulty perceptions and misconceptions about cancer made access to PC difficult.
The study emphasize the need for and provide a roadmap for developing context-specific and culturally appropriate CBPC services to address the identified challenges and needs. The findings point towards education of CHWs in PC; improving community awareness about cancer, PC, government support schemes; ensuring an uninterrupted supply of essential medicines; and developing active linkages within the community and with NGOs to address the financial, transportation, educational, vocational and other social needs as some of the strategies to ensure holistic CBPC services.
Clinical Trial Registry of India (CTRI/2023/04/051357).
本研究旨在探讨印度北部一个癌症负担高的农村地区癌症患者的姑息治疗(PC)需求和获得途径的障碍。
采用参与式行动研究(PAR)方法。计划、进行和开发了情景评估、社区宣传研讨会(CSW)和逐户调查三个 PAR 周期。采用平行收敛混合方法,收集和分析逐户调查的定量数据以及 CSW 和调查员实地记录的定性数据,以全面了解 PC 的需求和获得途径的障碍。采用描述性统计和主题分析。
共进行了 27 次 CSW,涉及 526 名利益相关者。使用支持性和姑息治疗指标(SPICT-4ALL)和埃德蒙顿症状评估系统(ESAS)工具分别对 256 名癌症患者进行 PC 需求和症状负担评估。根据 SPICT 评估,所有患者(n=256)均满足一般和/或癌症特异性 PC 指标。大多数患者(56.6%)有≥1 种中重度症状,最常见的症状是疲倦、疼痛和食欲不振。定性分析结果生成了三个主题:未满足的需求、照顾负担和障碍与挑战。癌症影响了患者及其家属生活的各个领域,导致了身心社会痛苦。社会耻辱、歧视、同情态度以及缺乏情感和物质支持,导致了癌症患者及其照顾者的心理社会痛苦。对 PC 的认识不足、附近的医疗保健设施、交通、基本药物、受过培训的人力以及 PC 教育、勾结、对社会歧视的恐惧、对癌症的错误看法和误解,使得获得 PC 变得困难。
该研究强调了需要制定特定于背景和文化的综合姑息治疗服务,并提供了路线图,以解决已确定的挑战和需求。研究结果指出,需要对社区卫生工作者进行姑息治疗教育;提高社区对癌症、姑息治疗、政府支持计划的认识;确保基本药物的不间断供应;并在社区内部以及与非政府组织建立积极的联系,以满足财务、交通、教育、职业和其他社会需求,作为确保综合姑息治疗服务的一些策略。
印度临床试验注册处(CTRI/2023/04/051357)。