Department of Anthropology, University of California, Santa Barbara, Santa Barbara, California, United States of America.
Department of Anthropology, University of Utah, Salt Lake City, Utah, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2024 Oct 14;19(10):e0306205. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0306205. eCollection 2024.
The economic, socio-political, and cultural significance of camelids in the Andean region is well-recognized, yet an understanding of their management evolution over pre-historical periods remains limited. This study aims to fill this gap by conducting the first cross-regional assessment of camelid pastoralism in Peru from 900 BCE to 1470 CE, using stable carbon and nitrogen isotopic compositions from the bone collagen and fibers of 577archaeological camelids across 21 sites. This research investigates the spatio-temporal shifts in camelid dietary habits, focusing on how the rise of intensive agriculture may have influenced change and led to the evolution of distinct roles for camelids in coastal versus non-coastal Andean economies. Our analysis indicates an increase in δ13C values over time on the coast, suggesting a shift towards maize-based camelid diets. Conversely, δ13C values decrease over time in highland environments, suggesting camelids consumed relatively more wild C3 forage and/or cultivated crops such as tubers. The study also reveals a significant positive relationship between latitude and δ15N values, suggesting increasing environmental aridity enriches δ15N in bone collagen. After controlling for this latitudinal effect, we observe a rise in δ15N values in both coastal and non-coastal camelids, suggesting that in later periods camelids may have been foddered in agricultural fields that were enriched with guano or dung fertilizer used to intensify production. Importantly, this research uncovers a distinct dietary divergence between coastal and inland camelids. The observed divergence in diets suggests contrasting socio-economic uses of camelids, where coastal camelids were predominantly involved in ceremonial and political activities, while those in non-coastal areas were crucial to the subsistence economy.
安第斯地区的骆驼科动物在经济、社会政治和文化方面具有重要意义,但对其史前时期管理演变的理解仍然有限。本研究旨在通过对秘鲁 900 年至 1470 年间的骆驼游牧业进行首次跨区域评估来填补这一空白,使用来自 21 个遗址的 577 只考古骆驼的骨骼胶原和纤维中的稳定碳和氮同位素组成。本研究调查了骆驼饮食习惯的时空变化,重点研究了集约农业的兴起如何影响了变化,并导致骆驼在沿海和非沿海安第斯经济中的作用发生了演变。我们的分析表明,沿海地区的 δ13C 值随时间推移而增加,表明以玉米为基础的骆驼饮食的转变。相反,在高海拔环境中,δ13C 值随时间推移而降低,表明骆驼食用了相对更多的野生 C3 草料和/或块茎等栽培作物。该研究还揭示了纬度与 δ15N 值之间存在显著的正相关关系,表明环境干旱度的增加会使骨骼胶原中的 δ15N 富集。在控制了这种纬度效应之后,我们观察到沿海和非沿海骆驼的 δ15N 值都有所上升,这表明在后期,骆驼可能被喂养在农业领域,这些领域富含鸟粪或粪便肥料,用于提高产量。重要的是,这项研究揭示了沿海和内陆骆驼之间明显的饮食差异。观察到的饮食差异表明,骆驼的社会经济用途存在差异,沿海地区的骆驼主要参与仪式和政治活动,而内陆地区的骆驼则对维持生计经济至关重要。