Mojiri Shahin, Soleymani Mohammad Reza, Sajadi Haniye Sadat, Ashrafi-Rizi Hasan, Sahebzadeh Mandana, Demneh Mohsen Taheri
Health Information Technology Research Center, Isfahan University of Medical Sciences, Isfahan, Iran.
Health Management and Economic Research Center, Isfahan University of Medical Sciences, Isfahan, Iran.
J Educ Health Promot. 2024 Aug 29;13:305. doi: 10.4103/jehp.jehp_861_23. eCollection 2024.
Production, publication, and effective of academic research in health policy-making are tools to strengthen interactions between policy-makers, the scientific community, and the public. The purpose of this study was to identify the key factors of knowledge translation in the policy-making of the health system in Iran using the structural analysis method.
This future study was conducted using the foresight structural analysis method for a 10-year horizon in Iran from 2022 to 2031. Initially, 183 factors were identified by literature review and interviews with experts. In the next step, factors were reduced to 34 factors based on the research team's opinions by merging similar items and removing fewer related items. Then, 34 factors were sent to the experts through an online questionnaire. Nineteen factors were identified with importance and uncertainty above the average. Then, the average degree of cross-impact of the selected factors in the matrix was scored by 11 experts in a focus group meeting, ranged from 3 (strong) to 1 (weak). The cross-impact of these factors was analyzed using MICMAC software.
Five factors, including "policy-making method," "role and function of universities," "specialized services of knowledge brokering," "international conflicts," and "policy-makers' trust in university researches," were identified as key factors due to their high influence and effectiveness.
The results of this study will help the research managers of the universities to be more informed and, therefore, more successful in their planning for more efficient utilization of the knowledge and evidence from academic research by knowing the factors influencing the translation of knowledge.
卫生政策制定中学术研究的产出、发表及有效性是加强政策制定者、科学界和公众之间互动的工具。本研究的目的是运用结构分析法确定伊朗卫生系统政策制定中知识转化的关键因素。
本前瞻性研究采用远见结构分析法,对伊朗2022年至2031年的10年前景进行研究。最初,通过文献综述和专家访谈确定了183个因素。下一步,根据研究团队的意见,通过合并相似项目和去除相关性较低的项目,将因素减少到34个。然后,通过在线问卷将34个因素发送给专家。确定了19个重要性和不确定性高于平均水平的因素。然后,在一次焦点小组会议上,由11位专家对矩阵中所选因素的交叉影响平均程度进行评分,范围从3(强)到1(弱)。使用MICMAC软件分析这些因素的交叉影响。
确定了五个因素,包括“决策方法”“大学的作用和功能”“知识中介的专业服务”“国际冲突”以及“政策制定者对大学研究的信任”,因其具有高影响力和有效性而被视为关键因素。
本研究结果将有助于大学的研究管理人员更了解情况,从而在规划中更成功地通过了解影响知识转化的因素,更有效地利用学术研究中的知识和证据。