Grimell Jan
Department of Sociology, Faculty of Social Sciences, Umeå University, Umeå, Sweden.
Front Sociol. 2024 Oct 4;9:1389924. doi: 10.3389/fsoc.2024.1389924. eCollection 2024.
As service members transition from deployment to civilian life, they are also expected to reintegrate into society. An important part of this process is to "soften up" veteran or warrior identities and open up the self for both existing and new identities, mindsets, and ways of life. Past research has shown that the warrior mindset, in particular, can have negative health implications in the long run. The mindset can be costly, not only for the individual and their loved ones, but also for the healthcare services and other agencies. This article draws from a recent interview study with 24 deployed Swedish veterans suffering from deteriorating mental health without receiving a clinical diagnosis. Purposeful sampling was conducted with the support of the medical staff at the Veterans' Clinic at Uppsala University Hospital. Participants had been screened for posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) but had not received a clinical diagnosis. This constitutes a large and understudied patient group in the clinic. The medical staff selected patients based on the following criteria: deteriorating mental health, increased suffering related to PTSD symptoms, and issues related to moral issues, existential concerns, and identity. The sample included veterans from both the Swedish Armed Forces and other deploying agencies. Of the 24 interviewees, 19 were from the Swedish Armed Forces (16 men and three women), and five (four women and one man) were deployed by other agencies. The number of overseas deployments varied widely, with some interviewees having completed 1-2 deployments, while others had completed 3-8. Additionally, some interviewees had interrupted planned or ongoing deployments for various reasons. At the time of the interviews, none were serving full-time in the armed forces; all were veterans. The interviews took place during an intense wave of COVID-19 infections in Sweden in early 2022, so the majority were conducted via videoconference. The participants' veteran identities were abductively analyzed through the mask of secrecy, the stoic mask, and the mask of denial, which are elements of the "Mask of the Warrior." This mask functions to safeguard mission focus, to endure, to execute tasks in extremely stressful situations, and to solve operational tasks during deployments and combat operations. The analysis of the interviews suggests that certain elements in these powerful veteran identities can serve as breeding grounds for suffering later in life. The veterans in the study tended to be stoic about their deteriorating mental health, kept the suffering to themselves, and denied the harmful aspects of their deployments. Thus, the Mask of the Warrior played a counterproductive role for the individual, their friends and family, and life in the aftermath of deployments. Another implication of secrecy and denial occurred on the societal or macro and system levels due to the absence of sufficient insight, knowledge, and understanding of veterans among personnel within the healthcare system and other agencies. This made it difficult for the healthcare system, and other relevant agencies, to offer adequate care and to understand the participants' health issues during sick leave. The perceived absence of societal and organizational rewards and benefits for veterans who risk their mental health and lives during deployment can be seen as a failing implicit work contract. This lack of recognition may lead to the corrosion of character.
随着军人从部署状态过渡到平民生活,他们还需要重新融入社会。这一过程的一个重要部分是“淡化”退伍军人或战士身份,为现有的和新的身份、思维方式及生活方式敞开自我。过去的研究表明,尤其是战士思维模式从长远来看可能对健康产生负面影响。这种思维模式代价高昂,不仅对个人及其亲人如此,对医疗服务机构和其他机构也是如此。本文取材于最近一项对24名心理健康状况恶化但未得到临床诊断的瑞典退伍军人的访谈研究。在乌普萨拉大学医院退伍军人诊所医务人员的支持下进行了有目的抽样。参与者已接受创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)筛查,但未得到临床诊断。这在诊所中是一个庞大且研究不足的患者群体。医务人员根据以下标准选择患者:心理健康状况恶化、与PTSD症状相关的痛苦加剧,以及与道德问题、生存问题和身份认同相关的问题。样本包括来自瑞典武装部队和其他部署机构的退伍军人。在24名受访者中,19人来自瑞典武装部队(16名男性和3名女性),5人(4名女性和1名男性)由其他机构部署。海外部署的次数差异很大,一些受访者完成了1 - 2次部署,而另一些人完成了3 - 8次。此外,一些受访者因各种原因中断了计划中的或正在进行的部署。在访谈时,没有人在武装部队全职服役;所有人都是退伍军人。访谈在2022年初瑞典新冠疫情感染高峰期进行,所以大多数访谈是通过视频会议进行的。通过保密面具、坚忍面具和否认面具对参与者的退伍军人身份进行溯因分析,这些面具是“战士面具”的组成部分。这种面具的作用是维护任务焦点、忍受痛苦、在极端压力情况下执行任务,以及在部署和战斗行动中解决作战任务。访谈分析表明,这些强大的退伍军人身份中的某些元素可能成为日后痛苦的滋生地。研究中的退伍军人往往对自己不断恶化的心理健康保持坚忍,独自承受痛苦,并否认部署带来的有害方面。因此,战士面具对个人、他们的朋友和家人以及部署后的生活起到了适得其反的作用。保密和否认的另一个影响出现在社会或宏观及系统层面,因为医疗系统和其他机构的人员对退伍军人缺乏足够的洞察力、知识和理解。这使得医疗系统和其他相关机构在病假期间难以提供充分的护理并理解参与者的健康问题。对于那些在部署期间冒着心理健康和生命危险的退伍军人,社会和组织层面缺乏认可和福利,可以被视为一份失败的隐性工作契约。这种缺乏认可可能导致品格的侵蚀。