Ni Tiffany, Cebron Urska, Zuo Kevin J, Stefaniuk Stephanie, Snell Laura, Dengler Jana
Temerty Faculty of Medicine, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada.
Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, HELIOS Klinikum Emil von Behring Berlin-Zehlendorf, Berlin, Germany.
Plast Surg (Oakv). 2024 Nov;32(4):735-742. doi: 10.1177/22925503231175483. Epub 2023 Jun 7.
Professional achievement awards are an important factor in recruitment, promotion, and faculty review within academic institutions. Studies have shown that subconscious, gender-based assumptions of individuals and their work in traditionally male-dominated fields lead to more positive evaluations of men than women, a phenomenon present among scientific and medical award committees. This study examined gender representation among recipients of major North American plastic surgery society awards over the last 50 years. Recipient lists of major achievement awards bestowed by ten American and Canadian plastic surgery societies between 1970 and 2020 were accessed online or by direct contact with the society. Awardee gender, institution affiliation, graduation year, fellowship status, and additional major awards received were recorded. Comparisons were made between gender representation among society presidents, board membership, general society memberships, attending physicians, and plastic surgery residency enrolment. Thirty-two major awards given by ten plastic surgery societies were included. Six hundred and twenty-five awards were conferred, of which 47 recipients were female (7.5%). Of the 121 individuals that received multiple major awards, 8 were female. Two-thirds of female awardees (72%) were clinical plastic surgeons and the remainder were scientists. Over the past 50 years, there has been a gradual increase in the proportion of female award winners. Despite a gradual increase in the proportion of female awardees in major plastic surgery societies, female plastic surgeons remain underrepresented among awardees, with less than 10% of major awards conferred to females.
专业成就奖是学术机构招聘、晋升和教师评估中的一个重要因素。研究表明,在传统男性主导领域中,对个人及其工作存在基于性别的潜意识假设,这导致对男性的评价比对女性更积极,这种现象在科学和医学奖项委员会中存在。本研究调查了过去50年北美主要整形外科协会奖项获得者中的性别代表性。通过在线或直接联系协会,获取了1970年至2020年间美国和加拿大十个整形外科协会授予的主要成就奖获得者名单。记录了获奖者的性别、机构隶属关系、毕业年份、奖学金状况以及获得的其他主要奖项。对协会主席、董事会成员、普通会员、主治医生和整形外科住院医师招生中的性别代表性进行了比较。纳入了十个整形外科协会颁发的32个主要奖项。共颁发了625个奖项,其中47名获奖者为女性(7.5%)。在获得多个主要奖项的121人中,有8名女性。三分之二的女性获奖者(72%)是临床整形外科医生,其余是科学家。在过去50年中,女性获奖者的比例逐渐增加。尽管主要整形外科协会中女性获奖者的比例逐渐增加,但女性整形外科医生在获奖者中的代表性仍然不足,授予女性的主要奖项不到10%。