Mukkamala Ramakrishna, Schnetz Michael P, Khanna Ashish K, Mahajan Aman
From the Department of Anesthesiology and Perioperative Medicine, University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.
Department of Bioengineering, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.
Anesth Analg. 2024 Oct 23. doi: 10.1213/ANE.0000000000007216.
Intraoperative hypotension prediction has been increasingly emphasized due to its potential clinical value in reducing organ injury and the broad availability of large-scale patient datasets and powerful machine learning tools. Hypotension prediction methods can mitigate low blood pressure exposure time. However, they have yet to be convincingly demonstrated to improve objective outcomes; furthermore, they have recently become controversial. This review presents the current state of intraoperative hypotension prediction and makes recommendations on future research. We begin by overviewing the current hypotension prediction methods, which generally rely on the prevailing mean arterial pressure as one of the important input variables and typically show good sensitivity and specificity but low positive predictive value in forecasting near-term acute hypotensive events. We make specific suggestions on improving the definition of acute hypotensive events and evaluating hypotension prediction methods, along with general proposals on extending the methods to predict reduced blood flow and treatment effects. We present a start of a risk-benefit analysis of hypotension prediction methods in clinical practice. We conclude by coalescing this analysis with the current evidence to offer an outlook on prediction methods for intraoperative hypotension. A shift in research toward tailoring hypotension prediction methods to individual patients and pursuing methods to predict appropriate treatment in response to hypotension appear most promising to improve outcomes.
由于术中低血压预测在减少器官损伤方面具有潜在临床价值,且大规模患者数据集和强大的机器学习工具广泛可得,其受到的关注日益增加。低血压预测方法可缩短低血压暴露时间。然而,这些方法尚未被确凿证明能改善客观预后;此外,最近它们引发了争议。本综述介绍了术中低血压预测的现状,并对未来研究提出建议。我们首先概述当前的低血压预测方法,这些方法通常将当前平均动脉压作为重要输入变量之一,在预测近期急性低血压事件时通常具有良好的敏感性和特异性,但阳性预测值较低。我们对改进急性低血压事件的定义和评估低血压预测方法提出了具体建议,同时还提出了将这些方法扩展到预测血流减少和治疗效果的一般性建议。我们在临床实践中对低血压预测方法进行了初步的风险效益分析。我们通过将这一分析与现有证据相结合,对术中低血压预测方法的前景进行了展望。将研究方向转向为个体患者量身定制低血压预测方法,并寻求预测针对低血压的适当治疗方法,似乎最有希望改善预后。