Department of Disease Control and Environmental Health, Makerere University, School of Public Health, Kampala, Uganda.
The Centre for Global Safe Water, Sanitation and Hygiene, Rollins School of Public Health, Emory University, Atlanta, GA, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2024 Oct 24;19(10):e0312604. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0312604. eCollection 2024.
Hand hygiene compliance is one of the key performance indicators for infection prevention and control programmes, patient safety and quality of health services. WHO guidelines and the patient centred approach stress the need to increase patient involvement in hand hygiene promotion in healthcare settings. Patients' and health care workers' perspectives are critical for developing interventions to foster patient involvement in promoting hand hygiene. This study explored perceptions of health care workers and patients towards patients' involvement in hand hygiene promotion.
An exploratory qualitative study was conducted in four health facilities: three public, and one private non-profit in central Uganda. We conducted key informant interviews (KIIs) with health care workers and focus group discussions (FGDs) with patients. Respondents were asked their views about a patient reminding a health care worker to practice hand hygiene and how best this can be done. Interviews were audio-recorded, and transcribed. Thematic content analysis was used.
We led seven FGDs grouped by sex (6 participants each), with patients from different units of the study health care facilities and 23 KIIs with the in-charges of the health care facilities, wards, and infection control committee members. The majority of the KIIs were in the age category 30 to 45 years (10/23), females (14/23), and 7/23 were nurses by cadre. For the FGD participants, the majority were aged 30 to 45 years (23/42), 24/42 were females, 21/42 had attained secondary education as their highest level of education and 21/42 were Catholics. The health care workers' and patients' views towards patients' participation in promoting hand hygiene among health care workers are presented according to the four themes that emerged: i) Patients reminding health care workers to practice hand hygiene was offensive; ii) Patients fear of negative response from health care workers, including being denied or receiving poor quality services; iii) Role of management in influencing hand hygiene (patient reminding a health care workers to wash hands could be acceptable in private health facilities compared to the public ones); iv) Suggestions on how patients' reminders to health care workers can be done, included empowering patients to do the reminders in a friendly and polite approach to the HCW.
Patients are reluctant to remind health workers to practice hand hygiene, because they feel it is confrontational and embarrassing, while health care workers find it offensive. Patient involvement seems to threaten patient-provider relationships. However patient empowerment was reported to be critical in promoting it and this is in-line with the hand hygiene guidelines.
手部卫生依从性是感染预防和控制计划、患者安全和医疗服务质量的关键绩效指标之一。世界卫生组织的指南和以患者为中心的方法强调需要增加患者在医疗机构中参与促进手部卫生的程度。患者和医护人员的观点对于制定干预措施以促进患者参与促进手部卫生至关重要。本研究探讨了医护人员和患者对患者参与手部卫生促进的看法。
在乌干达中部的四家医疗机构(三家公立医院和一家私立非营利性医院)进行了一项探索性定性研究。我们对医护人员进行了关键知情人访谈(KII),并对患者进行了焦点小组讨论(FGD)。受访者被问及他们对患者提醒医护人员进行手部卫生的看法,以及如何最好地做到这一点。访谈进行了录音,并进行了转录。使用了主题内容分析。
我们进行了七次 FGD,按性别分组(每组 6 人),参与者来自研究医疗机构的不同科室,进行了 23 次 KII,受访者为医疗机构的负责人、病房负责人和感染控制委员会成员。大多数 KII 参与者的年龄在 30 至 45 岁之间(10/23),女性(14/23),7/23 是护士。对于 FGD 参与者,大多数参与者的年龄在 30 至 45 岁之间(23/42),24/42 是女性,21/42 接受过中学教育,是他们的最高学历,21/42 是天主教徒。医护人员和患者对患者参与促进医护人员手部卫生的看法,根据出现的四个主题呈现:i)患者提醒医护人员进行手部卫生是冒犯性的;ii)患者担心会得到医护人员的负面回应,包括被拒绝或得到质量差的服务;iii)管理层在影响手部卫生方面的作用(患者提醒医护人员洗手在私立医疗机构可能比在公立医院更能被接受);iv)关于患者如何提醒医护人员的建议,包括授权患者以友好和礼貌的方式向 HCW 提出提醒。
患者不愿意提醒医护人员进行手部卫生,因为他们觉得这是对抗性和尴尬的,而医护人员则觉得这是冒犯性的。患者参与似乎威胁到医患关系。然而,报告称患者赋权对于促进这一点至关重要,这与手部卫生指南一致。