Bourguignon Lucie, Lukas Louis P, Kondiles Bethany R, Tong Bobo, Lee Jaimie J, Gomes Tomás, Tetzlaff Wolfram, Kramer John L K, Walter Matthias, Jutzeler Catherine R
Department of Health Sciences and Technology, ETH Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland.
SIB Swiss Institute of Bioinformatics, Lausanne, Switzerland.
Commun Med (Lond). 2024 Oct 24;4(1):213. doi: 10.1038/s43856-024-00638-0.
Complications arising from acute traumatic spinal cord injury (SCI) are routinely managed by various pharmacological interventions. Despite decades of clinical application, the potential impact on neurological recovery has been largely overlooked. This study aims to highlight commonly administered drugs with potential disease-modifying effects.
This systematic literature review included studies referenced in PubMed, Scopus and Web of Science from inception to March 31st, 2021, which assess disease-modifying properties on neurological and/or functional recovery of drugs routinely administered following spinal cord injury. Drug effects were classified as positive, negative, mixed, no effect, or not (statistically) reported. Risk of bias was assessed separately for animal, randomized clinical trials, and observational human studies.
We analyzed 394 studies conducting 486 experiments that evaluated 144 unique or combinations of drugs. 195 of the 464 experiments conducted on animals (42%) and one study in humans demonstrate positive disease-modifying properties on neurological and/or functional outcomes. Methylprednisolone, melatonin, estradiol, and atorvastatin are the most common drugs associated with positive effects. Two studies on morphine and ethanol report negative effects on recovery.
Despite a large heterogeneity observed in study protocols, research from bed to bench and back to bedside provides an alternative approach to identify new candidate drugs in the context of SCI. Future research in human populations is warranted to determine if introducing drugs like melatonin, estradiol, or atorvastatin would contribute to enhancing neurological outcomes after acute SCI.
急性创伤性脊髓损伤(SCI)引起的并发症通常通过各种药物干预进行处理。尽管已经临床应用了数十年,但对神经恢复的潜在影响在很大程度上被忽视了。本研究旨在强调具有潜在疾病修饰作用的常用药物。
本系统文献综述纳入了从创刊至2021年3月31日在PubMed、Scopus和Web of Science中引用的研究,这些研究评估了脊髓损伤后常规使用的药物对神经和/或功能恢复的疾病修饰特性。药物作用被分类为阳性、阴性、混合、无作用或未(统计学)报告。分别对动物研究、随机临床试验和观察性人体研究进行偏倚风险评估。
我们分析了394项研究,这些研究进行了486次实验,评估了144种单一药物或药物组合。在464项动物实验中有195项(42%)以及一项人体研究显示对神经和/或功能结局具有积极的疾病修饰特性。甲基强的松龙、褪黑素、雌二醇和阿托伐他汀是最常见的具有积极作用的药物。两项关于吗啡和乙醇的研究报告了对恢复的负面影响。
尽管在研究方案中观察到很大的异质性,但从 bench 到 bedside 再回到 bench 的研究提供了一种在SCI背景下识别新候选药物的替代方法。有必要在人群中开展进一步研究,以确定引入褪黑素、雌二醇或阿托伐他汀等药物是否有助于改善急性SCI后的神经结局。