Kristensen Kieran, Alhatali Badria, Zahran Tharwat El, Kazzi Ziad
Emory University School of Medicine, Atlanta, GA, USA.
Middle East and North Africa Clinical Toxicology Association, Muscat, Oman.
J Med Toxicol. 2025 Jan;21(1):42-50. doi: 10.1007/s13181-024-01038-5. Epub 2024 Oct 25.
Poison Centers are vital to prevent and manage exposures to chemicals, toxins, and ionizing radiation. However, many countries still lack sufficient poison information center services. Within the World Health Organization's Eastern Mediterranean Regional Office (EMRO) region, we were not able to identify a formal assessment of its toxicological resources. We sought to assess the clinical toxicological resources in the EMRO region and the attitudes, needs, and perspective of the workforce in that region. METHODS: This was a two part survey study. First, we developed a poison center questionnaire and scoring system based on the World Health Organization's Guidelines for Establishing a Poison Center; this instrument was administered by phone to poison center directors and faculty in the EMRO region. Questions assessed for the presence or absence of important poison center capabilities listed in the WHO guidelines, and points were assigned based on response. Secondly, we administered an electronic workforce survey to clinical toxicology professionals in the region; participant eligibility for the workforce survey was based on the membership roster of MENATOX.
Out of 22 EMRO countries, 16 countries have an established poison center, and 14 of 16 participated in the poison center survey. The results reflected a wide variability in capabilities among countries. Areas such as call centers, clinical toxicology units, laboratory services, and data management were relatively lacking while some other areas including toxicovigilance, chemical incidents and emergencies, antidotes/antivenoms, poisoning information sources, and the availability of free services were relatively stronger. Twenty-seven out of 32 workforce respondents were physicians. Results from that survey highlighted a desire for more support from government and better compensation.
Our study identified areas of need for the EMRO region. The poison center survey results reflect large disparities among countries with some areas being stronger than others. The workforce survey highlighted issues such as compensation and government recognition. Overall, a formal assessment of individual poison centers can provide benchmarks to drive improvement of services, but further research is needed to identify and characterize country-specific needs.
毒物中心对于预防和处理化学品、毒素及电离辐射暴露至关重要。然而,许多国家仍缺乏足够的毒物信息中心服务。在世界卫生组织东地中海区域办事处(EMRO)区域内,我们未能找到对其毒理学资源的正式评估。我们试图评估EMRO区域的临床毒理学资源以及该区域工作人员的态度、需求和观点。
这是一项分为两部分的调查研究。首先,我们根据世界卫生组织建立毒物中心的指南制定了一份毒物中心调查问卷和评分系统;该工具通过电话向EMRO区域的毒物中心主任和教员发放。问题评估了世界卫生组织指南中列出的重要毒物中心能力的有无,并根据回答打分。其次,我们对该区域的临床毒理学专业人员进行了一项电子工作人员调查;工作人员调查的参与者资格基于中东和北非毒理学协会(MENATOX)的成员名册。
在22个EMRO国家中,16个国家设有毒物中心,16个中的14个参与了毒物中心调查。结果反映出各国能力差异很大。呼叫中心、临床毒理学部门、实验室服务和数据管理等领域相对缺乏,而其他一些领域,包括药物警戒、化学事故与紧急情况、解毒剂/抗蛇毒血清、中毒信息来源以及免费服务的可用性则相对较强。32名工作人员受访者中有27名是医生。该调查结果突出了对政府更多支持和更好薪酬的渴望。
我们的研究确定了EMRO区域的需求领域。毒物中心调查结果反映出各国之间存在巨大差异,有些领域比其他领域更强。工作人员调查突出了薪酬和政府认可等问题。总体而言,对各个毒物中心的正式评估可以提供基准以推动服务改进,但需要进一步研究来确定并描述各国的具体需求。