Müller Malina, Lintener Hannah, Henkel Vivien, Pilz Andreas, Halsby Kate, Malerczyk Claudius, Madhava Harish, Moïsi Jennifer C, Yu Holly, Schley Katharina
WifOR Institute, 64283 Darmstadt, Germany.
Division of Public Health, Social and Preventive Medicine, Center for Preventive Medicine and Digital Health, Medical Faculty Mannheim, Heidelberg University, 68167 Mannheim, Germany.
Vaccines (Basel). 2024 Oct 12;12(10):1165. doi: 10.3390/vaccines12101165.
Tick-borne encephalitis (TBE) is a viral infection affecting the central nervous system (CNS) with potential long-term consequences including neurological sequelae. Vaccination is critical to reduce TBE morbidity and mortality, as no antiviral treatment is available. The World Health Organization (WHO) defines areas with an incidence of ≥5 cases/100,000 PPY as highly endemic and recommends that vaccination is offered to all individuals in these areas. However, access to TBE vaccination depends on recommendations and funding by national or subnational decision-makers. We assessed if TBE vaccination could offer good value for money at incidences below this threshold.
A closed-cohort Markov model was developed to estimate the cost-effectiveness of TBE vaccination. We compared primary vaccination applied to the whole population (aged above 1 year) and to a subpopulation aged between 60 and 85 years to a scenario without vaccination. Since TBE incidence is often underestimated, we included under-ascertained TBE cases and non-CNS TBE infections. Germany was used as a case study due to the availability of detailed incidence data.
Our incidence threshold analysis showed that TBE vaccination offers good value for money well below the WHO threshold in most of the analyzed scenarios.
Our results support a recommendation for TBE vaccination even in settings with low numbers of reported cases, especially for older patients. Furthermore, this analysis identified major research gaps regarding the costs, utilities, and clinical progression of TBE.
蜱传脑炎(TBE)是一种影响中枢神经系统(CNS)的病毒感染,可能会产生包括神经后遗症在内的长期后果。由于没有抗病毒治疗方法,接种疫苗对于降低TBE的发病率和死亡率至关重要。世界卫生组织(WHO)将发病率≥5例/10万人口年(PPY)的地区定义为高流行区,并建议在这些地区为所有个体提供疫苗接种。然而,能否获得TBE疫苗接种取决于国家或次国家级决策者的建议和资金。我们评估了在发病率低于该阈值的情况下,TBE疫苗接种是否具有良好的性价比。
建立了一个封闭队列马尔可夫模型来估计TBE疫苗接种的成本效益。我们将应用于整个人口(1岁以上)和60至85岁亚人群的初次疫苗接种与未接种疫苗的情况进行了比较。由于TBE发病率往往被低估,我们纳入了未确诊的TBE病例和非CNS TBE感染。由于可获得详细的发病率数据,以德国为例进行研究。
我们的发病率阈值分析表明,在大多数分析场景中,TBE疫苗接种在远低于WHO阈值的情况下就具有良好的性价比。
我们的结果支持即使在报告病例数较少的情况下也推荐接种TBE疫苗,尤其是对老年患者。此外,该分析确定了关于TBE的成本、效用和临床进展方面的主要研究空白。