Diarsvitri Wienta, Garianto Efyluk, Indrawati Roostantia, Sulistiani Wiwik
Department of Community Medicine, Faculty of Medicine, Hang Tuah University, Surabaya 60244, Indonesia.
Department of Medical Pharmacy, Faculty of Medicine, Hang Tuah University, Surabaya 60244, Indonesia.
J Adv Med Educ Prof. 2024 Oct 1;12(4):235-242. doi: 10.30476/jamp.2024.101936.1949. eCollection 2024 Oct.
Medical schools face substantial challenges in objectively selecting the best applicants, and the admission process can impact medical students' academic performance. This study aimed to estimate the students' academic success in the preclinical stage of undergraduate medical education using admission tests.
This cross-sectional study was conducted on 1,193 students' records from the 2014 to 2019 cohorts. The students' admission data comprised the cohort, sex, admission track, psychological test, and academic tests. The academic success was based on the student's end-year academic evaluation. Data were analyzed using contingency and Kendall's tau b tests with IBM SPSS Statistics version 16.0 for Windows.
Most of the 1,193 preclinical medical students' records included in the study were females (68.1%), from the regular admission track (78.5%), from the considered psychology test category (52.8%), and had an academic admission test of less than or equal to the median. (51.6%). Most students (89.7%) met all the academic requirements to pass the end-year evaluation. The bivariate analyses showed significant correlations between academic success and cohort (p<0.001), psychology test (p=0.005), and academic test (p<0.001). The analyses showed no significant correlation between academic success and sex (p=0.324), and admission track (p=0.128).
This study indicated that cohort and psychology tests could estimate the student's academic success at the preclinical stage of undergraduate medical education. The admission criteria related to the academic tests during the admission process should be re-evaluated, so that the academic tests could select the best students among the applicants.
医学院校在客观选拔最优秀申请者方面面临巨大挑战,而录取过程会影响医学生的学业表现。本研究旨在通过入学考试评估本科医学教育临床前阶段学生的学业成就。
本横断面研究对2014年至2019年入学批次的1193名学生的记录进行了分析。学生的录取数据包括入学批次、性别、录取途径、心理测试和学业测试。学业成就基于学生的年终学业评估。使用IBM SPSS Statistics 16.0 for Windows软件,通过列联表和肯德尔tau-b检验对数据进行分析。
本研究纳入的1193名临床前医学生记录中,大多数为女性(68.1%),来自常规录取途径(78.5%),属于所考虑的心理测试类别(52.8%),且学业入学测试成绩小于或等于中位数(51.6%)。大多数学生(89.7%)达到了年终评估合格的所有学业要求。双变量分析显示,学业成就与入学批次(p<0.001)、心理测试(p=0.005)和学业测试(p<0.001)之间存在显著相关性。分析表明,学业成就与性别(p=0.324)和录取途径(p=0.128)之间无显著相关性。
本研究表明,入学批次和心理测试可以评估本科医学教育临床前阶段学生的学业成就。应重新评估录取过程中与学业测试相关的录取标准,以便学业测试能够从申请者中选拔出最优秀的学生。