Waqas Ahmed, Correia Jorge Cesar, Ahmad Maaz, Akhtar Tooba Nadeem, Meraj Hafsa, Angelakis Ioannis, Pataky Zoltan
Department of Primary Care & Mental Health, Institute of Population Health, University of Liverpool, Liverpool, UK.
Unit of Therapeutic Patient Education, WHO Collaborating Centre, Department of Medicine, University Hospitals of Geneva, Geneva, Switzerland.
Glob Ment Health (Camb). 2024 Oct 10;11:e78. doi: 10.1017/gmh.2024.68. eCollection 2024.
This systematic review aimed to review therapeutic patient education (TPE) programmes in managing psychiatric disorders, considering the diversity in delivering agents, intervention formats, targeted skills, and therapeutic outcomes.
Comprehensive database searches, including Web of Science, PubMed, and COCHRANE, were conducted from September 2019 to January 2023, yielding 514 unique records, with 33 making it through rigorous evaluation for full-text review. Eleven studies met the inclusion criteria, focusing on various psychiatric disorders such as depression, bipolar disorder, psychosis, and multiple serious mental illnesses. A total of 38 studies were included from our previous review to supplement the current database search.
TPE programmes exhibited diversity in delivering agents and intervention formats, with a notable presence of multidisciplinary teams and various professionals. The interventions prioritized coping strategies and disease management techniques, though the extent varied based on the disorder. Effectiveness was heterogeneous across studies; some interventions showed significant benefits in areas such as symptom management, coping, and functional improvement, while others reported no significant outcomes.
The findings underscore the potential of TPE in psychiatric care, revealing its multifaceted nature and varied impact. TPE not only addresses deficits but also leverages patients' existing strengths and capabilities. Despite the reported benefits, a portion of the interventions lacked statistical significance, indicating the necessity for continuous refinement and evaluation.
本系统评价旨在回顾治疗性患者教育(TPE)项目在管理精神障碍方面的情况,同时考虑实施主体、干预形式、目标技能和治疗效果的多样性。
2019年9月至2023年1月期间,对包括科学网、PubMed和Cochrane在内的综合数据库进行了检索,共获得514条独特记录,其中33条通过严格评估进入全文审查。11项研究符合纳入标准,聚焦于各种精神障碍,如抑郁症、双相情感障碍、精神病和多种严重精神疾病。从我们之前的综述中纳入了38项研究,以补充当前的数据库检索。
TPE项目在实施主体和干预形式上表现出多样性,多学科团队和各类专业人员显著参与。干预措施优先考虑应对策略和疾病管理技术,不过其程度因障碍类型而异。各研究的效果参差不齐;一些干预措施在症状管理、应对和功能改善等方面显示出显著益处,而其他一些则未报告显著结果。
研究结果强调了TPE在精神科护理中的潜力,揭示了其多面性和不同影响。TPE不仅解决缺陷,还利用患者现有的优势和能力。尽管有报道称其有益处,但部分干预措施缺乏统计学意义,这表明有必要持续改进和评估。