Zambezi Denise, Viljoen Frans
LLD LLM LLB (University of Pretoria).
LLD (University of Pretoria) LLM (University of Cambridge) LLB (University of Pretoria), Professor of International Human Rights Law, Centre for Human Rights, Faculty of Law, University of Pretoria.
Int J Transgend Health. 2024 Feb 5;25(4):791-803. doi: 10.1080/26895269.2023.2273364. eCollection 2024.
The transgender population is one of the most marginalized and misunderstood population groups in South Africa. Despite a progressive and inclusive human rights-based legal framework, transgender people in South Africa are vulnerable to multiple human rights violations, including inequality and grave healthcare disparities. This study aims to assess the healthcare disparities experienced by transgender persons in South Africa. In South Africa, transgender people are legally entitled to equality and the right to access healthcare services. The article examines sparsely explored discrepancies and recommends how a transgender person's right to access healthcare can be strengthened through a comprehensive human rights approach. The methodology involved semi-structured interviews with transgender respondents and healthcare experts. The sample comprised 43 transgender respondents aged between 23 and 45 residing in Gauteng, Mpumalanga, North West and the Western Cape and a multi-disciplinary group of nine healthcare professionals working in South African health institutions. The data was analyzed through relevant thematic analysis. The majority of transgender participants and healthcare experts reported that there are transgender-related inequalities in the healthcare system, including stigma and discrimination, exclusionary and culturally incompetent health services and limited availability of competent healthcare services. There is a need for South Africa to intensify its application of transgender human rights to bridge the gap between lived experiences and the law. Comprehensive and explicit transgender-inclusive laws must be developed. Diverse transgender people must participate in the law and policy-making process. Activism, advocacy, and strategic litigation should be used effectively by relevant parties to create awareness and impact change.
在南非,跨性别群体是最边缘化且最易被误解的人群之一。尽管有基于人权的进步且包容的法律框架,但南非的跨性别者仍易遭受多种人权侵犯,包括不平等和严重的医疗保健差距。本研究旨在评估南非跨性别者所经历的医疗保健差距。在南非,跨性别者在法律上有权享有平等以及获得医疗服务的权利。本文探讨了鲜有研究的差异,并建议如何通过全面的人权方法来加强跨性别者获得医疗保健的权利。研究方法包括对跨性别受访者和医疗保健专家进行半结构化访谈。样本包括43名年龄在23岁至45岁之间、居住在豪登省、普马兰加省、西北省和西开普省的跨性别受访者,以及在南非医疗机构工作的由九名医疗专业人员组成的多学科小组。通过相关主题分析对数据进行了分析。大多数跨性别参与者和医疗保健专家报告称,医疗保健系统中存在与跨性别相关的不平等现象,包括污名化和歧视、排他性且缺乏文化能力的医疗服务以及合格医疗服务的可及性有限。南非需要加强对跨性别者人权的应用,以弥合生活经历与法律之间的差距。必须制定全面且明确的包容跨性别者的法律。不同的跨性别者必须参与法律和政策制定过程。相关各方应有效利用激进主义、宣传和战略诉讼来提高认识并推动变革。