University of Pittsburgh School of Public Health, 130 De Soto St, Pittsburgh, PA 15261. Email:
Am J Manag Care. 2024 Oct 1;30(10):e297-e304. doi: 10.37765/ajmc.2024.89622.
To compare racial and ethnic disparities in cost-related medical care and dental care barriers and use of vision care among near-poor Medicare beneficiaries in Medicare Advantage (MA) vs traditional Medicare (TM) overall and stratified by supplemental insurance enrollment.
Cross-sectional analysis of 2015-2019 data from the nationally representative Medicare Current Beneficiary Survey.
Propensity score-weighted difference-in-disparities analyses comparing Black-White and Hispanic-White disparities in MA vs TM among near-poor Medicare beneficiaries with incomes between 101% and 250% of the federal poverty level. We assessed differences in cost-related medical care barriers and cost-related dental care barriers as well as receipt of annual eye exams in MA vs TM.
For cost-related barriers to medical care, Hispanic-White disparities were narrower by 8.8 (95% CI, -14.0 to -3.6) percentage points in MA relative to TM but differences in Black-White disparities were not statistically significant. MA was not associated with narrower differences in Hispanic-White or Black-White disparities in dental care access. Higher proportions of Black and Hispanic beneficiaries in MA received an annual eye exam vs White beneficiaries in both MA and TM. MA was associated with narrower racial disparities primarily compared with TM without supplemental insurance.
Among near-poor Black and Hispanic Medicare beneficiaries, MA was associated with greater use of vision care and narrowing of some disparities in cost-related access barriers vs TM. However, MA did not uniformly narrow racial/ethnic disparities in access and use. These findings highlight the importance of maintaining and enhancing features of Medicare coverage that may promote equitable access to care, including additional benefits and lower cost sharing.
比较医疗保险优势计划(MA)与传统医疗保险(TM)中近贫困 Medicare 受益人群在与费用相关的医疗保健和牙科保健障碍以及视力保健使用方面的种族和民族差异,并按补充保险参保情况进行分层比较。
对来自全国代表性 Medicare 现行受益人调查的 2015-2019 年数据进行横截面分析。
采用倾向评分加权差异差异分析方法,比较收入在联邦贫困线的 101%至 250%之间的近贫困 Medicare 受益人群中 MA 与 TM 之间的黑-白和西班牙裔-白人群体差异。我们评估了 MA 与 TM 之间与费用相关的医疗保健障碍和与费用相关的牙科保健障碍以及年度眼部检查的接受情况方面的差异。
在与医疗保健相关的费用障碍方面,与 TM 相比,MA 下西班牙裔-白人群体的差异缩小了 8.8(95%CI,-14.0 至 -3.6)个百分点,但黑-白人群体差异没有统计学意义。MA 与牙科保健获取方面的西班牙裔-白人和黑-白人群体差异缩小无关。在 MA 中,与 TM 相比,更多的黑人和西班牙裔受益人群接受了年度眼部检查,而在 MA 和 TM 中,白人受益人群的比例均更高。与 TM 相比,MA 主要与没有补充保险的 TM 相比,与种族差异缩小有关。
在近贫困的黑人和西班牙裔 Medicare 受益人群中,与 TM 相比,MA 与更多的视力保健使用和与费用相关的获取障碍方面的一些差异缩小有关。然而,MA 并未统一缩小种族/民族在获取和使用方面的差异。这些发现强调了维持和增强 Medicare 覆盖范围的特征的重要性,这些特征可能会促进公平获得医疗保健,包括额外的福利和降低成本分担。