Salmon Danielle M, Badenhorst Marelise, Keung Sierra, Kerr Zachary Yukio, Register-Mihalik Johna K, Romanchuk Janelle, Sullivan S John, Sutherland Christina, Whatman Chris, Walters Simon R
New Zealand Rugby, Wellington, New Zealand.
School of Sport and Recreation, Sports Performance Research Institute New Zealand, Auckland University of Technology, Auckland, New Zealand.
Eur J Sport Sci. 2024 Dec;24(12):1883-1902. doi: 10.1002/ejsc.12213. Epub 2024 Nov 5.
Concerns around concussion highlight the need for strategies to improve the implementation and translation of concussion guidelines in community sports. This study assessed players' utilisation and compliance with New Zealand Rugby's Concussion Management Pathway (CMP). This pragmatic, mixed methods study comprised of concussion injury surveillance and mapping of players' healthcare touchpoints through the CMP. Semi-structured interviews were conducted to understand stakeholders' experiences. Over the season, 27 different healthcare pathways were identified with 28% of players progressing through all phases of the CMP (ideal pathway). Of the 206 suspected concussions reported over the season, 70% were logged in the CMP phone App, and 89% of these had an associated valid baseline concussion assessment. Prior to returning to contact training, 64% of players obtained a medical clearance. One theme, 'belief in the value of pathway' was identified as a facilitator across all CMP components. Themes such as 'concussion knowledge and the nature of concussion'; 'communication between stakeholders and sufficient information on the process'; and 'strong relationships and clarity around responsibilities' were identified as facilitators across several pathway components. Other facilitators included 'ease and timing of general practitioner access'; 'the phone App as facilitator to logging'; and 'spotting for concussion as a team'. Additionally, the findings signify baseline testing as a potential pre-cursor to overall CMP compliance. Strategies that support the facilitators identified in this study may further enhance compliance.
对脑震荡的担忧凸显了在社区体育中改进脑震荡指南实施和转化的策略的必要性。本研究评估了球员对新西兰橄榄球联盟脑震荡管理路径(CMP)的使用情况和遵循程度。这项务实的混合方法研究包括脑震荡损伤监测以及通过CMP绘制球员的医疗接触点。进行了半结构化访谈以了解利益相关者的经历。在整个赛季中,确定了27种不同的医疗路径,28%的球员完成了CMP的所有阶段(理想路径)。在该赛季报告的206起疑似脑震荡中,70%记录在CMP手机应用程序中,其中89%有相关的有效脑震荡基线评估。在恢复接触性训练之前,64%的球员获得了医学许可。一个主题“对路径价值的信念”被确定为所有CMP组成部分的促进因素。“脑震荡知识和脑震荡的性质”;“利益相关者之间的沟通以及关于该过程的充分信息”;以及“牢固的关系和责任明确”等主题被确定为几个路径组成部分的促进因素。其他促进因素包括“全科医生就诊的便捷性和及时性”;“手机应用程序作为记录的促进工具”;以及“团队对脑震荡的识别”。此外,研究结果表明基线测试是总体CMP遵循情况的潜在先兆。支持本研究中确定的促进因素的策略可能会进一步提高遵循程度。