Mangset Marte, Orupabo Julia
Department of Sociology and Human Geography, University of Oslo, Oslo, Norway.
Institute for Social Research, Oslo, Norway.
Br J Sociol. 2025 Mar;76(2):226-240. doi: 10.1111/1468-4446.13165. Epub 2024 Nov 14.
Academics influence not only knowledge production but also selection to the labour market and policy development. They have power. Despite the sociological attention paid to class in higher education, few studies have examined the way in which class interferes with the careers of those navigating from being students to becoming scholars. Building on Bourdieu's theory of social reproduction, this study examines how class influences different groups' experiences of becoming academics. Based on 60 interviews with Norwegian scholars in their early to mid-careers, the analysis identifies the kind of classed resources that are in play in the unequal access to academic positions. Beyond more classical resources, such as financial, cultural, and psychological certainty, the interviewees point to the significance of an early familiarity with the rules of the game and strategic navigation of the academic system. We use these findings to discuss and nuance Pierre Bourdieu's perspectives on the role of incorporated, practical consciousness and disinterestedness in class reproduction in the academic world. This theoretical contribution facilitates the combined analysis of the implicit and the explicit ways that dominant classes preserve their position in the hierarchy, which the study demonstrates as key to social reproduction in academic careers.
学者不仅影响知识的产生,还影响劳动力市场的选拔和政策的制定。他们拥有权力。尽管社会学界对高等教育中的阶层问题给予了关注,但很少有研究考察阶层是如何影响那些从学生转变为学者的人的职业发展的。基于布迪厄的社会再生产理论,本研究考察了阶层是如何影响不同群体成为学者的经历的。通过对60位处于职业生涯早期至中期的挪威学者进行访谈,分析确定了在获得学术职位的不平等过程中发挥作用的那种阶层化资源。除了更传统的资源,如经济、文化和心理上的确定性之外,受访者还指出了尽早熟悉游戏规则以及在学术体系中进行策略性运作的重要性。我们利用这些发现来讨论并细化皮埃尔·布迪厄关于内化的实践意识和无私在学术界阶层再生产中的作用的观点。这一理论贡献有助于对主导阶层在等级制度中维持其地位的隐性和显性方式进行综合分析,该研究表明这是学术生涯中社会再生产的关键。