National Center for Global Health, Istituto Superiore Di Sanità, Rome, Italy.
Department of Public Health and Infectious Diseases, Sapienza University of Rome, Rome, Italy.
BMC Med. 2024 Nov 14;22(1):532. doi: 10.1186/s12916-024-03746-9.
Long-COVID symptoms remain incompletely defined due to a large heterogeneity in the populations studied, case definitions, and settings of care. The aim of this study was to assess, in patients accessing care for Long-COVID, the profile of symptoms reported, the possible clustering of symptoms and cases, the functional status compared to pre-infection, and the impact on working activity.
Multicentre cohort study with a collection of both retrospective and prospective data. Demographics, comorbidities, severity and timing of acute COVID, subjective functional status, working activity and presence of 30 different symptoms were collected using a shortened version of the WHO Post COVID-19 Case Report Form. The impact on working activity was assessed in multivariable logistic regression models. Clustering of symptoms was analysed by hierarchical clustering and the clustering of cases by two-step automatic clustering.
The study evaluated 1297 individuals (51.5% women) from 30 clinical centres. Men and women had different profiles in terms of comorbidities, vaccination status, severity and timing of acute SARS-CoV-2 infection. Fatigue (55.9%) and dyspnea (47.2%) were the most frequent symptoms. Women reported more symptoms (3.6 vs. 3.1, p < 0.001), with a significantly higher prevalence of memory loss, difficult concentration, cough, palpitation or tachycardia, dermatological abnormalities, brain fog, headache and visual disturbances. Dyspnea was more common in men. In the cluster analysis of the 19 more common symptoms, five aggregations were found: four two-symptom clusters (smell and taste reduction; anxiety and depressed mood; joint pain or swelling and muscle pain; difficult concentration and memory loss) and one six-symptom cluster (brain fog, equilibrium/gait disturbances, headache, paresthesia, thoracic pain, and palpitations/tachycardia). In a multivariable analysis, headache, dyspnea, difficult concentration, disturbances of equilibrium or gait, visual disturbances and muscular pain were associated with reduced or interrupted working activity. Clustering of cases defined two clusters, with distinct characteristics in terms of phase and severity of acute infection, age, sex, number of comorbidities and symptom profile.
The findings provide further evidence that Long-COVID is a heterogeneous disease with manifestations that differ by sex, phase of the pandemic and severity of acute disease, and support the possibility that multiple pathways lead to different clinical manifestations.
由于研究人群、病例定义和治疗环境存在较大异质性,长期 COVID 症状仍未得到充分定义。本研究旨在评估在因长期 COVID 就诊的患者中,报告的症状特征、症状和病例的可能聚类、与感染前相比的功能状态以及对工作活动的影响。
这是一项多中心队列研究,收集了回顾性和前瞻性数据。使用世界卫生组织 COVID-19 后病例报告表的简化版收集人口统计学、合并症、急性 COVID 的严重程度和时间、主观功能状态、工作活动以及 30 种不同症状的存在情况。使用多变量逻辑回归模型评估对工作活动的影响。通过层次聚类分析症状聚类,通过两步自动聚类分析病例聚类。
该研究评估了来自 30 个临床中心的 1297 名个体(51.5%为女性)。男性和女性在合并症、疫苗接种状态、急性 SARS-CoV-2 感染的严重程度和时间方面存在不同的特征。疲劳(55.9%)和呼吸困难(47.2%)是最常见的症状。女性报告的症状更多(3.6 比 3.1,p<0.001),记忆力减退、注意力难以集中、咳嗽、心悸或心动过速、皮肤异常、头脑模糊、头痛和视力障碍的患病率明显更高。呼吸困难在男性中更为常见。在 19 种更常见症状的聚类分析中,发现了五个聚集:四个两个症状聚集(嗅觉和味觉减退;焦虑和抑郁情绪;关节疼痛或肿胀和肌肉疼痛;注意力难以集中和记忆力减退)和一个六个症状聚集(头脑模糊、平衡/步态障碍、头痛、感觉异常、胸痛和心悸/心动过速)。在多变量分析中,头痛、呼吸困难、注意力难以集中、平衡或步态障碍、视力障碍和肌肉疼痛与工作减少或中断有关。病例聚类定义了两个聚类,在急性感染的阶段和严重程度、年龄、性别、合并症数量和症状特征方面具有不同的特征。
研究结果进一步表明,长期 COVID 是一种异质性疾病,其表现因性别、大流行阶段和急性疾病严重程度而异,并支持多种途径导致不同临床表现的可能性。