Skovlund Sebastian Venge, Østergaard Mark Skovbye Eg, Seeberg Karina G V, Suetta Charlotte, Aagaard Per, Andersen Lars Louis, Sundstrup Emil
National Research Centre for the Working Environment, Lersø Parkallé 105, 2100 Copenhagen, Denmark.
Scand J Work Environ Health. 2025 Jan 1;51(1):3-14. doi: 10.5271/sjweh.4195. Epub 2024 Nov 17.
Knee pain is highly prevalent and disabling among the general and working population. This systematic review explored the effectiveness of workplace-based interventions on knee pain among workers.
A PICO-guided systematic search was performed in PubMed and Web of Science Core Collection for articles published from 2003 until January 2023. Eligible articles included randomized and non-randomized controlled trials assessing the effect of workplace-based interventions on knee pain among currently employed adult workers. The quality assessment and evidence synthesis adhered to the systematic review approach, which the Institute for Work & Health developed, and was focused on developing practical recommendations for stakeholders.
Of the 13 identified studies, 11 medium- and high-quality studies were entered into the evidence synthesis. Importantly, none of the included studies specifically aimed at reducing of knee pain. Still, among the included studies, a strong level of evidence suggested no benefit of workplace-based physical exercise/activity intervention on knee pain. The level of evidence was deemed too uncertain to guide current policy/practices for ergonomic and multifaceted interventions. No intervention types were associated with negative effects on knee pain.
The current evidence-base pertaining to workplace-based prevention and management of knee pain is insufficient to guide effective preventive workplace practice or policy development. Considering the global prevalence and health impact of knee pain, development and implementation of effective workplace interventions aimed at prevention and management of knee pain is needed.
膝关节疼痛在普通人群和劳动人口中极为普遍且会导致功能障碍。本系统评价探讨了基于工作场所的干预措施对劳动者膝关节疼痛的有效性。
在PubMed和科学网核心合集数据库中进行了一项由PICO指导的系统检索,检索2003年至2023年1月发表的文章。符合条件的文章包括评估基于工作场所的干预措施对当前在职成年劳动者膝关节疼痛影响的随机和非随机对照试验。质量评估和证据综合遵循工作与健康研究所制定的系统评价方法,重点是为利益相关者制定实用建议。
在13项纳入研究中,11项中高质量研究被纳入证据综合分析。重要的是,纳入的研究均未专门针对减轻膝关节疼痛。不过,在纳入研究中,有充分证据表明基于工作场所的体育锻炼/活动干预对膝关节疼痛没有益处。证据水平被认为过于不确定,无法指导当前关于人体工程学和多方面干预的政策/实践。没有干预类型与膝关节疼痛的负面影响相关。
目前关于基于工作场所的膝关节疼痛预防和管理的证据基础不足以指导有效的工作场所预防实践或政策制定。考虑到膝关节疼痛的全球患病率及其对健康的影响,需要制定和实施旨在预防和管理膝关节疼痛的有效工作场所干预措施。