Huang Shan, Ishii Hidetoki
Nagoya University, Japan.
Educ Psychol Meas. 2024 Oct 1:00131644241279882. doi: 10.1177/00131644241279882.
Despite numerous studies on the magnitude of differential item functioning (DIF), different DIF detection methods often define effect sizes inconsistently and fail to adequately account for testing conditions. To address these limitations, this study introduces the unified M-DIF model, which defines the magnitude of DIF as the difference in item difficulty parameters between reference and focal groups. The M-DIF model can incorporate various DIF detection methods and test conditions to form a quantitative model. The pretrained approach was employed to leverage a sufficiently representative large sample as the training set and ensure the model's generalizability. Once the pretrained model is constructed, it can be directly applied to new data. Specifically, a training dataset comprising 144 combinations of test conditions and 144,000 potential DIF items, each equipped with 29 statistical metrics, was used. We adopt the XGBoost method for modeling. Results show that, based on root mean square error (RMSE) and BIAS metrics, the M-DIF model outperforms the baseline model in both validation sets: under consistent and inconsistent test conditions. Across all 360 combinations of test conditions (144 consistent and 216 inconsistent with the training set), the M-DIF model demonstrates lower RMSE in 357 cases (99.2%), illustrating its robustness. Finally, we provided an empirical example to showcase the practical feasibility of implementing the M-DIF model.
尽管针对差异项目功能(DIF)的大小进行了大量研究,但不同的DIF检测方法往往对效应大小的定义不一致,并且未能充分考虑测试条件。为了解决这些局限性,本研究引入了统一的M-DIF模型,该模型将DIF的大小定义为参考组和焦点组之间项目难度参数的差异。M-DIF模型可以纳入各种DIF检测方法和测试条件,以形成一个定量模型。采用预训练方法利用一个具有充分代表性的大样本作为训练集,并确保模型的通用性。一旦构建了预训练模型,就可以直接将其应用于新数据。具体而言,使用了一个包含144种测试条件组合和144,000个潜在DIF项目的训练数据集,每个项目配备29个统计指标。我们采用XGBoost方法进行建模。结果表明,基于均方根误差(RMSE)和偏差指标,M-DIF模型在两个验证集中均优于基线模型:在一致和不一致的测试条件下。在所有360种测试条件组合(144种与训练集一致,216种与训练集不一致)中,M-DIF模型在357例(99.2%)中表现出较低的RMSE,说明了其稳健性。最后,我们提供了一个实证例子来展示实施M-DIF模型的实际可行性。