Obure Vallery Auma, Juma Kenneth, Athero Sherine, Donzo Vekeh, Conteh-Khali Neneh, Ouedraogo Ramatou, Ushie Boniface Ayanbekongshie
African Population Health and Research Center, P.O. Box 10787, Nairobi, Kenya.
Clinton Health Access Initiative, Monrovia, Liberia.
Arch Public Health. 2024 Nov 21;82(1):220. doi: 10.1186/s13690-024-01446-7.
Abortion is largely restricted in Liberia and Sierra Leone, with exceptions under limited conditions. Consequently, women and girls seeking induced abortion care in these settings resort to unsafe methods, resulting in severe complications. Post-abortion care (PAC) is a lifesaving obstetric intervention to address abortion-related complications, but access to quality and comprehensive PAC in health facilities is daunting. Research on barriers to PAC, drawing on perspectives from diverse stakeholders, is critical to inform specific programmatic improvements to enhance access to quality PAC services.
This study explored stakeholders' perspectives on the barriers to quality PAC across health facilities in Liberia and Sierra Leone.
This cross-sectional qualitative study targeted PAC providers in selected health facilities and policy actors in Liberia and Sierra Leone. We conducted in-depth interviews with 33 healthcare providers - 8 in Liberia and 25 in Sierra Leone; and 13 policy actors - 8 in Liberia and 5 in Sierra Leone. The policy actors included representatives from religious institutions, ministries of health, civil society organizations, and non-government organizations working on sexual and reproductive health (SRH) issues. Audio files of the interviews were transcribed verbatim in the original language of the interview and translated into English by expert translators. A deductive and inductive approach was used to develop a codebook to code the interviews in Dedoose software. Data analysis was conducted using the thematic approach.
Diverse viewpoints of what constitutes quality PAC existed among stakeholders in Sierra Leone and Liberia, and these variations are reflected in their practices and behavior around PAC services. Our analysis revealed some weaknesses and gaps in PAC delivery, including a lack of trained providers, which was more pronounced in Sierra Leone than in Liberia. In both countries, the absence of functional PAC equipment, inadequate PAC supplies, and infrastructure-related challenges (e.g., lack of rooms with audio-visual privacy during PAC service) were commonly cited. Limited audio-visual privacy complicated provider-patient interactions, with providers mentioning that this makes patients withhold vital information during history-taking. Providers had no or limited knowledge of the law, and best practices around PAC, leading to delays, denial of services, overcharging fees, and stigmatization of some patients.
Despite existing policies and interventions on post-abortion, many health facilities in Liberia and Sierra Leone lack essential post-abortion care equipment and supplies and trained providers. There is a need to recruit and train willing providers, along with a clear referral system. Further, sensitizing health providers, stakeholders, and communities on abortion-related policies, guidelines, and value clarification could help improve post-abortion care service provision and uptake.
在利比里亚和塞拉利昂,堕胎受到严格限制,仅在有限条件下有例外情况。因此,在这些地区寻求人工流产护理的妇女和女孩会采用不安全的方法,从而导致严重并发症。流产后护理(PAC)是一种挽救生命的产科干预措施,用于处理与堕胎相关的并发症,但在医疗机构中获得高质量和全面的PAC却面临诸多困难。从不同利益相关者的角度研究PAC的障碍,对于为改善特定项目以增加获得高质量PAC服务的机会提供信息至关重要。
本研究探讨了利比里亚和塞拉利昂各医疗机构中利益相关者对高质量PAC障碍的看法。
这项横断面定性研究的对象是利比里亚和塞拉利昂选定医疗机构中的PAC提供者以及政策制定者。我们对33名医疗保健提供者进行了深入访谈——利比里亚8名,塞拉利昂25名;以及13名政策制定者——利比里亚8名,塞拉利昂5名。政策制定者包括宗教机构、卫生部、民间社会组织以及从事性与生殖健康(SRH)问题的非政府组织的代表。访谈的音频文件以访谈的原始语言逐字转录,并由专业翻译人员翻译成英语。采用演绎和归纳的方法制定了一个编码手册,以便在Dedoose软件中对访谈进行编码。数据分析采用主题分析法。
在塞拉利昂和利比里亚的利益相关者中,对于什么构成高质量PAC存在不同观点,这些差异反映在他们围绕PAC服务的实践和行为中。我们的分析揭示了PAC服务提供方面的一些弱点和差距,包括缺乏经过培训的提供者,这在塞拉利昂比在利比里亚更为明显。在这两个国家,普遍提到缺乏可用的PAC设备、PAC用品不足以及与基础设施相关的挑战(例如,在PAC服务期间缺乏具有视听隐私的房间)。有限的视听隐私使提供者与患者的互动变得复杂,提供者提到这使得患者在病史采集过程中隐瞒重要信息。提供者对法律以及PAC的最佳实践了解甚少或一无所知,导致服务延误、拒绝服务、多收费以及对一些患者的污名化。
尽管存在关于流产后护理的现有政策和干预措施,但利比里亚和塞拉利昂的许多医疗机构缺乏基本的流产后护理设备、用品以及经过培训的提供者。需要招募和培训愿意从事这项工作的提供者,并建立明确的转诊系统。此外,提高医疗保健提供者、利益相关者和社区对与堕胎相关的政策、指南以及价值观澄清的认识,可能有助于改善流产后护理服务的提供和利用情况。