Blais Annette, Ahmed Mavra, L'Abbé Mary, Sellen Daniel, Malik Vasanti
Department of Nutritional Sciences, Temerty Faculty of Medicine, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada.
Joannah and Brian Lawson Centre for Child Nutrition, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada.
Appl Physiol Nutr Metab. 2025 Jan 1;50:1-11. doi: 10.1139/apnm-2024-0083. Epub 2024 Nov 22.
Canada remains one of few Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) countries without a well-established nationally harmonized and funded school food program (SFP); however, the Canadian federal government recently announced the development and implementation of a national SFP that might supersede the uncoordinated patchwork of SFPs currently delivered across Canada. We designed and conducted novel survey research to systematically identify the characteristics of organization-led SFPs, building on previous research that focused on the characteristics of provincial and territorial government involvement in school food programming. An electronic survey was developed to include items deemed most relevant based on applicable literature and expert content validation, and distributed to organizations involved in the purchasing, planning, and/or preparation of school foods. Responses were categorized post hoc into the RE-AIM categories to assess SFP Reach, Effectiveness, Adoption, Implementation, and Maintenance. Analysis identified key SFP implementation characteristics (including funding source, payment model, and student eligibility), program components, SFP goals/mandates, and factors that determine what foods are served; and assessed correlations among key characteristics. Results from 67 SFPs across 10 provinces indicate considerable variability in SFP characteristics. SFP-delivering organizations reported a predominant goal of reducing student food insecurity, while nutrition and cost were cited as the main factors determining food served. Collectively, organizations were found to rely primarily on donations, while provincial funding accounted for only 30% of total funding. These findings reveal strengths and areas for improvement within Canada's current school food landscape and highlight important gaps that could be addressed with federal involvement.
加拿大仍是经济合作与发展组织(OECD)中少数几个没有完善的全国统一资助学校食品计划(SFP)的国家之一;然而,加拿大联邦政府最近宣布制定并实施一项全国性的SFP,该计划可能会取代目前加拿大各地实施的不协调的拼凑式SFP。我们在以前专注于省级和地区政府参与学校食品规划特点的研究基础上,设计并开展了新颖的调查研究,以系统地确定组织主导的SFP的特点。我们开发了一项电子调查,纳入了根据适用文献和专家内容验证确定为最相关的项目,并分发给参与学校食品采购、规划和/或准备的组织。事后将回复归类为RE-AIM类别,以评估SFP的覆盖范围、有效性、采用情况、实施情况和维持情况。分析确定了SFP实施的关键特征(包括资金来源、支付模式和学生资格)、计划组成部分、SFP目标/任务以及决定提供何种食品的因素;并评估了关键特征之间的相关性。来自10个省份67个SFP的结果表明,SFP特征存在很大差异。提供SFP的组织报告称,其主要目标是减少学生的粮食不安全状况,而营养和成本被认为是决定提供何种食品的主要因素。总体而言,各组织主要依赖捐赠,而省级资金仅占总资金的30%。这些发现揭示了加拿大当前学校食品领域的优势和改进领域,并突出了联邦政府参与可以解决的重要差距。