Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Herlev and Gentofte University Hospital DK-2730, Herlev, Denmark.
Department of Clinical Medicine, Faculty of Health and Medical Sciences, University of Copenhagen DK-2200, Copenhagen N, Denmark.
J Pregnancy. 2024 Nov 15;2024:1716798. doi: 10.1155/2024/1716798. eCollection 2024.
Many pregnant women are reluctant to follow the recommendation concerning oral iron prophylaxis due to concerns about gastrointestinal (GI) side effects. To assess the frequency of GI complaints during low-dose oral iron prophylaxis and compare three iron formulas in equipotent doses: ferrous fumarate versus ferrous bisglycinate versus ferrous sulphate, in healthy women with an uncomplicated single pregnancy. Results from two randomized, double-blind studies are reported: the Gentofte study comprising 404 women allocated into four groups taking 20, 40, 60, and 80 mg of elemental iron as ferrous fumarate/day and the Naestved study comprising 78 women allocated into two groups: 25 mg of elemental iron as ferrous bisglycinate/day and 50 mg of elemental iron as ferrous sulphate/day between meals from 15 to 19 weeks of gestation to delivery. GI complaints (nausea, vomiting, epigastric pain/pyrosis, belching, meteorism, borborygmi, intestinal colic, flatulence, loose stools, constipation, and use of laxatives), as well as black stools, were recorded by interview at the time of inclusion and at regular intervals during gestation. At inclusion, the frequency of total combined GI complaints in all women ( = 482) was 21%. The Gentofte study showed that in the groups taking 20-60 mg iron/day as fumarate, there was no association between the iron dose and the frequency of GI side effects. An iron dose of 80 mg as fumarate was associated with significantly higher frequencies of constipation and the use of laxatives. Comparing the three equipotent doses of iron formulas, which can prevent iron deficiency, ferrous bisglycinate 25 mg iron had the most favourable GI side effect profile, while ferrous fumarate 40 mg iron and ferrous sulphate 50 mg iron had higher but similar GI side effect profiles. The frequency of black stools increased with the iron dose. Ferrous bisglycinate 25 mg iron had a lower frequency of black stools (8%) than ferrous fumarate 40 mg iron (22%) and ferrous sulphate 50 mg iron (31%). Low-dose iron supplementation appears to have no clinically significant GI side effects, as none of the included women presented with GI complaints of such severity that it necessitated either reduction of iron dose, change to an alternative iron formula, or discontinuation of iron supplement. However, ferrous bisglycinate 25 mg iron/day is associated with significantly fewer GI complaints than ferrous fumarate 40 mg iron/day and ferrous sulphate 50 mg iron/day. Ferrous bisglycinate may be preferred for iron prophylaxis, especially in women experiencing GI side effects when taking other conventional iron formulas.
许多孕妇由于担心胃肠道(GI)副作用而不愿意遵循口服铁预防的建议。为了评估低剂量口服铁预防期间 GI 投诉的频率,并比较三种等剂量的铁配方:富马酸亚铁、甘氨酸亚铁和硫酸亚铁,在健康的单胎妊娠女性中。报告了两项随机、双盲研究的结果:Gentofte 研究包括 404 名女性,分为四组,每天分别服用 20、40、60 和 80mg 元素铁作为富马酸亚铁;Naestved 研究包括 78 名女性,分为两组:25mg 元素铁作为甘氨酸亚铁,50mg 元素铁作为硫酸亚铁,从 15 周到 19 周妊娠到分娩期间随餐服用。GI 投诉(恶心、呕吐、上腹痛/灼热感、打嗝、腹胀、肠鸣音、肠痉挛、气胀、腹泻、便秘和泻药使用)以及黑便,通过访谈在纳入时和妊娠期间定期记录。在纳入时,所有女性(=482 人)的总胃肠道综合投诉频率为 21%。Gentofte 研究表明,在每天服用 20-60mg 铁作为富马酸盐的组中,铁剂量与 GI 副作用的频率之间没有关联。服用 80mg 富马酸铁的剂量与便秘和泻药使用的频率显著增加有关。比较三种可预防缺铁的等剂量铁配方,甘氨酸亚铁 25mg 铁具有最有利的胃肠道副作用特征,而富马酸亚铁 40mg 铁和硫酸亚铁 50mg 铁具有更高但相似的胃肠道副作用特征。黑便的频率随着铁剂量的增加而增加。甘氨酸亚铁 25mg 铁的黑便频率(8%)低于富马酸亚铁 40mg 铁(22%)和硫酸亚铁 50mg 铁(31%)。低剂量铁补充似乎没有明显的胃肠道副作用,因为没有一名纳入的女性出现如此严重的胃肠道投诉,以至于需要减少铁剂量、改用替代铁配方或停止铁补充。然而,甘氨酸亚铁 25mg 铁/天与富马酸亚铁 40mg 铁/天和硫酸亚铁 50mg 铁/天相比,胃肠道投诉明显减少。甘氨酸亚铁可能更适合铁预防,尤其是在服用其他常规铁配方时出现胃肠道副作用的女性。