Department of Health, Welfare and Organisation. Postal Box Code (PB) 700, Østfold University College, Halden, 1757, Norway.
School of Public Health, University of Alberta, 11405 - 87 Avenue, Edmonton, T6G 1C9, Canada.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2024 Nov 28;24(1):1494. doi: 10.1186/s12913-024-11985-y.
Due to demographic changes in the Western world governments emphasize the need for viable solutions, e.g. through decentralization of specialist health care services and better coordination within and between health care services. Both Norway and Canada have been through health care reforms and initiatives aiming to improve continuity and coordination of services. Organizational change to primary care in both countries encompasses both team-based service delivery involving allied health professionals, and new blended payment models. The objective of this study was to explore patient pathways in primary healthcare from various health personnel's perspectives, and across various primary care organizations in Norway and Canada.
The study had a qualitative design, including interviews with physicians, nurses and managers (n = 19) in primary care, from a county in Norway and a region in Canada. Data were analyzed with a thematic approach, in line with recommendations from Braun & Clarke.
Three themes were identified: 1) Structural challenges, 2) Towards a more specialized primary health care and 3) Dedication could improve continuity. Findings indicate that coordinating health care services was assumed difficult due to different health care levels, funding systems, managements, electronic record systems and organizations. Hospitals were assumed more task oriented, while primary health care services were considered more care oriented, and this challenged the coordination across organizations. Primary care services were perceived to be more and more specialized, also representing a threat for coordination and continuity. Health care personnel in both countries perceived that dedicated personnel for each patient could improve information flow and continuity across services.
Achieving continuity and coordination of health care services seems challenging. Integration strategies seem essential for reducing silo thinking and fragmentation of health care services.
由于西方世界的人口结构变化,政府强调需要可行的解决方案,例如通过将专科医疗服务去中心化,以及更好地协调医疗服务内部和之间的关系。挪威和加拿大都经历了医疗改革和举措,旨在改善服务的连续性和协调性。这两个国家的基层医疗组织变革都包含了基于团队的服务交付,涉及到辅助医疗专业人员,以及新的混合支付模式。本研究的目的是从各种卫生人员的角度,以及从挪威和加拿大的各种基层医疗组织,探讨初级保健中的患者路径。
该研究采用定性设计,包括对挪威一个县和加拿大一个地区的基层医疗中的医生、护士和管理人员(n=19)进行访谈。数据采用主题分析方法进行分析,符合 Braun & Clarke 的建议。
确定了三个主题:1)结构挑战,2)走向更专业化的初级保健,3)敬业精神可以提高连续性。研究结果表明,由于不同的医疗保健水平、资金系统、管理、电子病历系统和组织,协调医疗服务被认为是困难的。医院被认为更注重任务,而基层医疗服务则被认为更注重护理,这对跨组织的协调构成了挑战。基层医疗服务被认为越来越专业化,这也对协调和连续性构成了威胁。这两个国家的医疗保健人员都认为,为每个患者配备专门的人员可以改善服务之间的信息流动和连续性。
实现医疗服务的连续性和协调性似乎具有挑战性。整合策略似乎对于减少医疗服务的孤岛思维和碎片化至关重要。