Blåhed Hanna, Jonsson Frida, Hurtig Anna-Karin
Department of Epidemiology and Global Health, Umeå University, Umeå, Sweden.
Arctic Research Centre (Arcum), Umeå University, Umeå, Sweden.
Int J Health Policy Manag. 2024;13:8372. doi: 10.34172/ijhpm.8372. Epub 2024 Nov 18.
In the context of a broader vision for primary healthcare (PHC) informed health systems, Sweden is following international trends by introducing the national "Good Quality and Local Health Care" reform. This reform seeks to establish a health system with primary care (PC) at the centre by emphasising aspects such as interorganisational collaboration and e-Health innovation. Since translating policy into practice may be challenging in rural areas due to resource constrains and normatively urban perspectives in national policy-making, this study explores how rural PC actors navigate the PHC vision in the context of a sparsely populated area of the Swedish north.
This was a single case study, focusing on a rural municipality in northern Sweden. Thematic analysis was applied to data collected through interviews and observations, resulting in the development of three themes.
The results indicate that the policies were suboptimally aligned with the needs of the rural municipality. The results highlighted enduring collaborations that predated the reform. These local alliances led to a resource allocation challenge, rendering the existing networks and reform efforts concurrently understaffed. Moreover, the reform's efforts to digitise healthcare faced impediments due to challenges associated with scaling up e-Health technology. Although key reform concepts such as person-centeredness and integrated care had already been put into practice, they were insufficiently acknowledged as such by external stakeholders.
Subjecting national health policy-making to scrutiny by different stakeholders through the use of rural proofing can lead to a more deliberate and impactful implementation of policies. Rural proofing facilitates the pre-emptive identification of potential shortcomings, thereby enabling the formulation of necessary adjustments that resonate with local needs. This study shows apparent misalignments between the national vision and the practical reality in rural areas, therefore calling for greater efforts to include rural perspectives in national policy-making.
在以初级卫生保健(PHC)为导向的更广泛卫生系统愿景背景下,瑞典顺应国际潮流,推行了全国性的“优质与地方卫生保健”改革。这项改革旨在建立一个以初级保健(PC)为核心的卫生系统,强调组织间协作和电子健康创新等方面。由于资源限制以及国家政策制定中存在的城市本位观念,在农村地区将政策转化为实践可能具有挑战性,因此本研究探讨了瑞典北部人口稀少地区的农村初级保健行为主体如何在初级卫生保健愿景下开展工作。
这是一项单案例研究,聚焦于瑞典北部的一个农村自治市。对通过访谈和观察收集的数据进行了主题分析,得出了三个主题。
结果表明,这些政策与农村自治市的需求未达到最佳契合。结果突出了改革之前就已存在的持久合作关系。这些地方联盟导致了资源分配难题,使现有网络和改革工作同时面临人员不足的问题。此外,由于扩大电子健康技术存在挑战,改革中医疗保健数字化的努力面临阻碍。尽管以患者为中心和综合护理等关键改革理念已经付诸实践,但外部利益相关者对此并未给予充分认可。
通过农村验证让不同利益相关者对国家卫生政策制定进行审查,可使政策实施更加审慎且有效。农村验证有助于预先识别潜在缺陷,从而能够做出符合当地需求的必要调整。本研究表明国家愿景与农村实际情况之间存在明显脱节,因此呼吁在国家政策制定中更加努力地纳入农村视角。