Dove Erica, Hewston Patricia, Wang Rosalie H, Patterson Kara K, Astell Arlene J
Rehabilitation Sciences Institute, Temerty Faculty of Medicine, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada.
Toronto Rehabilitation Institute, KITE Research Institute, University Health Network, Toronto, ON, Canada.
Front Dement. 2024 Nov 20;3:1456125. doi: 10.3389/frdem.2024.1456125. eCollection 2024.
Concerns about falling (e.g., low balance confidence) increase fall risk in older populations with balance impairments. Exercise can improve physical limitations associated with falls (e.g., poor balance), which are more prevalent in people with Mild Cognitive Impairment (MCI) and dementia. This scoping review aimed to understand exercise interventions targeting concerns about falling in people with MCI and dementia.
Using Arksey and O'Malley's five-stage scoping review framework, 968 search combinations were run across six electronic databases from inception to September 15, 2023. Articles were available in English full text, featured original peer-reviewed research with an intervention study design, targeted people with MCI or dementia with the exercise intervention, and included concerns about falling as an outcome measure.
Of the 2,111 articles screened, 27 met the inclusion criteria. Only one article looked at concerns about falling as a primary outcome; in the remaining studies, concerns about falling were a secondary outcome. Multi-modal interventions (i.e., containing more than one type of exercise) were most common, with balance and strength as the most frequently employed exercise types. Secondary results are presented on (i) intervention details, (ii) outcomes and measures for concerns about falling, (iii) participant accommodations, and (iv) components of effective interventions for concerns about falling.
There is a lack of focus on concerns about falling experienced by people with MCI and dementia. Although concerns about falling were not the primary outcome of most papers, the results highlight the potential of exercise interventions to help address concerns about falling and other fall risk factors (e.g., balance, cognition) in people with MCI and dementia.
对跌倒的担忧(如平衡信心不足)会增加存在平衡障碍的老年人群的跌倒风险。运动可以改善与跌倒相关的身体机能限制(如平衡能力差),而这种情况在轻度认知障碍(MCI)和痴呆症患者中更为普遍。本综述旨在了解针对MCI和痴呆症患者跌倒担忧的运动干预措施。
采用阿克西和奥马利的五阶段综述框架,在六个电子数据库中从建库至2023年9月15日进行了968次搜索组合。文章需为英文全文,具有原创的同行评审研究且采用干预研究设计,针对MCI或痴呆症患者进行运动干预,并将对跌倒的担忧作为结果指标。
在筛选的2111篇文章中,27篇符合纳入标准。只有一篇文章将对跌倒的担忧作为主要结果;在其余研究中,对跌倒的担忧为次要结果。多模式干预(即包含不止一种运动类型)最为常见,平衡训练和力量训练是最常用的运动类型。次要结果呈现于以下方面:(i)干预细节,(ii)对跌倒担忧的结果和测量方法,(iii)参与者适应性,以及(iv)针对跌倒担忧的有效干预措施的组成部分。
目前缺乏对MCI和痴呆症患者跌倒担忧的关注。尽管对跌倒的担忧并非大多数论文的主要结果,但研究结果凸显了运动干预在帮助解决MCI和痴呆症患者跌倒担忧及其他跌倒风险因素(如平衡、认知)方面的潜力。