van Stralen Renée Anne, Roelen Merel Charlotte Rosalie, Moerman Sophie, Witbreuk Melinda Maria Eva Helena, Witlox M Adhiambo, Ten Ham Arno, Eygendaal Denise, Reijman Max, Tolk Jaap Johannes
Orthopedics and Sports Medicine, Erasmus MC Universitair Medisch Centrum Rotterdam, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
Orthopedics and Sports Medicine, Erasmus MC Universitair Medisch Centrum Rotterdam, Rotterdam, The Netherlands.
BMJ Open. 2024 Dec 11;14(12):e091073. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2024-091073.
Up to one-third of patients with cerebral palsy (CP) develop hip migration. Current standard care for early hip migration is bilateral adductor-psoas tenotomy; however, the failure rate is relatively high with 34%-74% of patients with CP requiring secondary hip surgery. Using temporary medial hemiepiphysiodesis of the proximal femur (TMH-PF), the morphology of the hip can be changed. This technique aims to reduce further hip migration and the need for secondary surgical management. Further research is necessary to determine the benefit of TMH-PF in addition to adductor-psoas tenotomy. The hypothesis of this study is that TMH-PF combined with adductor-psoas release decreases the chance of progressive hip migration and the need for secondary hip surgery, compared with adductor-psoas release alone.
The GUIDANCE study is an open-label multicentre randomised controlled trial. Patients with CP aged between 2 and 8 years, with spastic CP-Gross Motor Function Classification System IV or V, hip abduction ≤40° and hip migration of 30%-50% can be included in this trial. They will be randomised into a control arm (adductor-psoas tenotomy) or an intervention arm (adductor-psoas tenotomy+TMH PH). The primary outcome will be treatment failure at 5-year follow-up. At 2-year follow-up a preliminary analysis will be performed. Secondary outcomes will be differences in patient-reported outcome measures (CPCHILD and CPG pain score), range of motion, radiological measurements including head shaft angle and hip migration percentage and three-dimensional (3D) morphological changes to the proximal femur. Furthermore, an analysis will be performed to identify predictors for treatment failure in both treatment arms.
The GUIDANCE study should provide evidence on the effectiveness of TMH-PF in addition to adductor-psoas tenotomy in children with CP with early hip migration. If beneficial, larger hip reconstructive procedures can be delayed or prevented, providing a distinct benefit for these vulnerable children. The study's strengths lie in its methodological framework, incorporating randomised allocation and intervention assessment. The main limitation is the inability to blind the treating physician or the researcher for the treatment arm the participant is allocated to. The results of the GUIDANCE study will be presented at scientific meetings and published in international peer-reviewed journals. The aim is to publish the results at 2 years follow-up and 5 years follow-up and to publish the results of the analysis on the 3D morphology of the hip after TMH-PF. Individual de-identified participant data that underlie the results from the GUIDANCE study and the study protocol will be shared if requested.
Clinical Trial Registry number: NCT06118736. Registered on 3 November 2023.
高达三分之一的脑瘫(CP)患者会出现髋关节移位。目前针对早期髋关节移位的标准治疗方法是双侧内收肌-腰大肌切断术;然而,失败率相对较高,34%-74%的CP患者需要进行二次髋关节手术。通过股骨近端临时内侧半骨骺阻滞术(TMH-PF),可以改变髋关节的形态。该技术旨在减少进一步的髋关节移位以及二次手术治疗的需求。除了内收肌-腰大肌切断术外,有必要进一步研究以确定TMH-PF的益处。本研究的假设是,与单纯内收肌-腰大肌松解术相比,TMH-PF联合内收肌-腰大肌松解术可降低髋关节进行性移位的几率以及二次髋关节手术的需求。
GUIDANCE研究是一项开放标签的多中心随机对照试验。年龄在2至8岁、患有痉挛性CP-粗大运动功能分类系统IV或V级、髋关节外展≤40°且髋关节移位30%-50%的CP患者可纳入本试验。他们将被随机分为对照组(内收肌-腰大肌切断术)或干预组(内收肌-腰大肌切断术+TMH-PF)。主要结局将是5年随访时的治疗失败情况。在2年随访时将进行初步分析。次要结局将包括患者报告的结局指标(CPCHILD和CPG疼痛评分)、活动范围、包括头干角和髋关节移位百分比在内的放射学测量以及股骨近端的三维(3D)形态变化。此外,将进行分析以确定两个治疗组中治疗失败的预测因素。
GUIDANCE研究应能提供证据,证明TMH-PF联合内收肌-腰大肌切断术对早期髋关节移位的CP儿童的有效性。如果有益,更大规模的髋关节重建手术可以推迟或避免,为这些脆弱儿童带来显著益处。该研究的优势在于其方法框架,包括随机分配和干预评估。主要局限性在于无法使治疗医生或研究人员对参与者被分配到的治疗组保持盲态。GUIDANCE研究的结果将在科学会议上展示并发表在国际同行评审期刊上。目标是在2年随访和5年随访时发表结果,并发表TMH-PF后髋关节3D形态分析的结果。如果有要求,将共享构成GUIDANCE研究结果和研究方案基础的个体去标识化参与者数据。
临床试验注册号:NCT06118736。于2023年11月3日注册。