Dulawan Julie Ann T, Ignacio Sharon D, Ang-Muñoz Cynthia D, Carlos Frances Ann B, Leochico Carl Froilan D
Philippine General Hospital, Manila, Philippines.
Region 2 Trauma and Medical Center, Bayombong, Nueva Vizcaya, Philippines.
Acta Med Philipp. 2024 Nov 15;58(20):20-28. doi: 10.47895/amp.v58i20.8713. eCollection 2024.
During the COVID-19 pandemic, social isolation and quarantine measures set to control the spread of the infection paved for the increased utilization of virtual methods of consultation and follow-up. Telerehabilitation allows access to rehabilitation services despite distance and makes possible the continuation of rehabilitation services despite the lack of face-to-face interaction. This is difficult for pediatric patients who are dependent on their caregivers for understanding and making decisions regarding their health. Loss of continuity of rehabilitation services led to poorer outcomes in children with disabilities. Although advantageous for them, pediatric patients may not benefit from telerehabilitation if caregivers have negative perceptions of the process and are unwilling to utilize the service.
This study determined caregivers' perceptions and willingness to participate in telerehabilitation as a method of outpatient follow-up for pediatric patients admitted to a COVID-referral center in a developing country.
The study utilized a descriptive cross-sectional design. Respondents were adults (≥19 years old) caring for pediatric patients admitted at non-COVID wards of the Philippine General Hospital and who were referred for rehabilitation services. A survey tool adapted from a previous study on willingness to utilize telemedicine among caregivers of pediatric patients was translated into the Filipino language and used in the study. A dataset from Excel was imported in STATA 16 (StataCorp, Texas, USA) and was exhaustively checked for completeness, accuracy, and consistency before analysis. The association between patient characteristics and willingness to utilize telerehabilitation for any app was determined using Pearson's chi-squared test or Fisher's exact test, as appropriate. The latter was used when more than 20% of the cells had an expected value of less than or equal to five. A value of less than 0.05 was considered significant for all tests.
Of 123 respondents, 92 (75%) reported willingness to utilize telerehabilitation for outpatient consultation and therapy using video calls or a customized telerehabilitation app when available. Among 31 (25%) respondents who were not willing or unsure of participation, the main reasons identified were preference for face-to-face, lack of financial resources/load, poor connectivity, and doubt about the effectiveness of telerehabilitation.Patients with younger age (Fisher's exact test, =0.023), low usage of video call service (Fisher's exact test, =0.020), and lack of available devices (Fisher's exact test, =0.015) significantly reduced willingness to utilize telerehabilitation. Caregiver age, sex, educational attainment, estimated monthly income, number of devices used, speed of internet connectivity, and technological behaviors did not show statistical significance in association with willingness to participate in telerehabilitation.Most caregivers recognized the usefulness of a service allowing transmission of health data to and from the hospital, consultation with a doctor in case of an emergency, sending of reminders for medical visits and therapy, and provision of a list of home exercises and nutritional recommendations. Telerehabilitation was perceived advantageous, but concerns regarding privacy, trust, lack of human contact, and technological difficulty were also present.
With high levels of willingness among caregivers, telerehabilitation is a viable method of providing rehabilitation services for the continuation of management after inpatient admission among pediatric patients. Limitations in its utilization include technological issues including the lack of devices, low level of service use, and slow internet connectivity. Although well perceived as advantageous, there are concerns regarding loss of human contact, difficulty in using technological devices, and trust and privacy issues that may affect utilization.
在新冠疫情期间,为控制感染传播而采取的社会隔离和检疫措施促使虚拟咨询和随访方法的使用增加。远程康复使人们能够不受距离限制获得康复服务,即使缺乏面对面互动也能继续提供康复服务。这对于依赖照顾者来理解和决定自身健康状况的儿科患者来说存在困难。康复服务的连续性中断会导致残疾儿童的预后较差。尽管远程康复对他们有益,但如果照顾者对该过程有负面看法且不愿意使用这项服务,儿科患者可能无法从中受益。
本研究确定了照顾者对参与远程康复作为发展中国家一家新冠转诊中心收治的儿科患者门诊随访方法的看法和意愿。
本研究采用描述性横断面设计。研究对象为照顾菲律宾总医院非新冠病房收治且被转诊接受康复服务的儿科患者的成年人(≥19岁)。一个改编自先前关于儿科患者照顾者使用远程医疗意愿的研究的调查工具被翻译成菲律宾语并用于本研究。来自Excel的数据集被导入到STATA 16(美国德克萨斯州的StataCorp公司)中,并在分析前对其完整性、准确性和一致性进行了详尽检查。根据情况,使用Pearson卡方检验或Fisher精确检验来确定患者特征与使用任何应用程序进行远程康复意愿之间的关联。当超过20%的单元格预期值小于或等于5时使用后者。所有检验中,P值小于0.05被认为具有统计学意义。
在123名受访者中,92名(75%)表示愿意在有视频通话或定制远程康复应用程序时,利用远程康复进行门诊咨询和治疗。在31名(25%)不愿意或不确定是否参与的受访者中,确定的主要原因是更喜欢面对面、缺乏资金/负担过重、网络连接差以及对远程康复效果的怀疑。年龄较小的患者(Fisher精确检验,P = 0.023)、视频通话服务使用频率低(Fisher精确检验,P = 0.020)以及缺乏可用设备(Fisher精确检验,P = 0.015)显著降低了使用远程康复的意愿。照顾者的年龄、性别、教育程度、估计月收入、使用的设备数量、网络连接速度和技术行为与参与远程康复的意愿之间未显示出统计学意义。大多数照顾者认识到一项允许在医院之间传输健康数据、在紧急情况下与医生咨询、发送医疗就诊和治疗提醒以及提供家庭锻炼和营养建议清单的服务的有用性。远程康复被认为是有利的,但也存在对隐私、信任、缺乏人际接触和技术困难的担忧。
由于照顾者的意愿度较高,远程康复是为儿科患者住院后继续管理提供康复服务的一种可行方法。其使用的局限性包括技术问题,如缺乏设备、服务使用水平低和网络连接速度慢。尽管被广泛认为是有利的,但存在对人际接触缺失、使用技术设备困难以及可能影响使用的信任和隐私问题的担忧。