Jansen Max P
Faculty of Social Sciences, Goethe University Frankfurt, Frankfurt am Main, Germany.
Institute for Social Research (IfS), Goethe University Frankfurt, Frankfurt am Main, Germany.
Front Psychol. 2024 Nov 12;15:1358279. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2024.1358279. eCollection 2024.
The Imposter Phenomenon (IP) is gaining increasing attention in academia, not only as an overall attractive research topic but also as a concern that especially affects members of minority groups. Nevertheless, there is little evidence for the occurrence and socio-structural correlates of the IP. Against the backdrop of a pressing need to contextualize the IP, this paper provides (1) an overview of the existing empirical evidence on the IP from a perspective that incorporates the role of social contexts, (2) highlights shortcomings in both existing theoretical approaches and methodological tools, (3) introduces the Impostor Phenomenon Short Scale (IPSS-3) as a novel, time-efficient and universally applicable IP measure, and (4) underscores that the IP, in fact, does not occur in a social vacuum but is closely intertwined with socio-structural characteristics. To this end, the paper draws on three distinct data sets gathered among German adolescents and adults for the development of the IPSS-3 (Study 1: = 271), its validation (Study 2: = 427), and to assess the IP's socio-structural correlates (Study 3: = 865). The findings demonstrate that the IPSS-3 represents the first time-efficient and universally applicable instrument suitable for capturing the IP in large-scale and longitudinal research designs, e.g., initiated in adolescence. Thus, the IPSS-3 can address key open questions related to age effects, the role of transitions in the life course, and systematic variations in IP intensity among different social groups.
冒名顶替现象(IP)在学术界正日益受到关注,这不仅是因为它是一个总体上颇具吸引力的研究课题,还因为它是一个特别影响少数群体成员的问题。然而,关于冒名顶替现象的发生及其社会结构关联的证据却很少。在迫切需要将冒名顶替现象置于具体情境中的背景下,本文提供了以下内容:(1)从纳入社会背景作用的视角对冒名顶替现象的现有实证证据进行概述;(2)强调现有理论方法和方法工具的不足之处;(3)介绍冒名顶替现象短量表(IPSS - 3),这是一种新颖、省时且普遍适用的冒名顶替现象测量工具;(4)强调冒名顶替现象实际上并非发生在社会真空中,而是与社会结构特征紧密交织在一起。为此,本文借鉴了在德国青少年和成年人中收集的三个不同数据集,用于开发IPSS - 3(研究1:n = 271)、对其进行验证(研究2:n = 427)以及评估冒名顶替现象的社会结构关联(研究3:n = 865)。研究结果表明,IPSS - 3首次成为一种省时且普遍适用的工具,适用于在大规模和纵向研究设计(例如始于青少年时期的研究)中捕捉冒名顶替现象。因此,IPSS - 3能够解决与年龄效应、人生历程中过渡阶段的作用以及不同社会群体中冒名顶替现象强度的系统差异相关的关键开放性问题。