Hennion Sophie, Fournier Valentyn, Derambure Philippe, Delelis Gérald, Schiaratura Loris
Centre de Référence des Épilepsies Rares, Service de Neurophysiologie Clinique, Unité d'épileptologie, Centre Hospitalier Universitaire de Lille, Lille, France; Inserm, U1172 - LilNCog - Lille Neuroscience & Cognition, Department of Clinical Neurophysiology, Lille, France.
Univ. Lille, CNRS, UMR 9193 - SCALab - Sciences Cognitives et Sciences Affectives, F-59000 Lille, France; Univ. Lille, ULR 4072 - PSITEC - Psychologie: Interactions, Temps, Emotions, Cognition, F-59000 Lille, France.
Epilepsy Behav. 2025 Feb;163:110216. doi: 10.1016/j.yebeh.2024.110216. Epub 2024 Dec 12.
People with epilepsy face stigma that impacts numerous aspects of their daily lives. Although the stigma surrounding people with epilepsy has been extensively documented, the mechanisms underlying it-such as cultural stereotypes-remain to be explored. Cultural stereotypes are widely shared beliefs within a cultural context about attributes typically associated with members of a particular group. This study, conducted within French society, has two primary objectives: 1) to define the content of cultural stereotypes associated with people suffering from epilepsy and 2) to examine how familiarity and knowledge about epilepsy influence these stereotypes. To explore these stereotypes, a free association task was conducted across three cultural groups (n = 96): (1) the general population, with low familiarity and knowledge about epilepsy (n = 39); (2) healthcare professionals without epilepsy specialization, who have more familiarity and knowledge than the general population (n = 38); and (3) healthcare professionals specialized in epilepsy, who have the highest familiarity and knowledge of the three groups (n = 29). All participants held higher education qualifications to ensure a more homogeneous socio-cultural background across groups. Using the software program "IraMuTeQ", we analyzed the diversity of terms each group associated with "people with epilepsy." Additionally, we examined the valence and typicality of cultural stereotypes in each group. The results reveal that, regardless of familiarity and knowledge levels, cultural stereotypes linked to epilepsy are generally negative. Across the entire sample, the most prototypical associations with people with epilepsy included "madness," "possession," "tongue," and "intellectual deficiency." The general population shares some cultural stereotypes with non-specialized healthcare professionals (e.g., "photosensitivity"), while non-specialized professionals share other associations with specialized healthcare professionals (e.g., "intellectual deficiency" and "mental illness"). However, no overlap was found between the cultural stereotypes of the general population and those of healthcare professionals specialized in epilepsy. Stereotypes related to epilepsy appear to be less typical among healthcare professionals compared to the general population. This distinction between cultural stereotypes and personal beliefs is further discussed below. Considering cultural stereotypes may allow for more tailored and effective interventions to reduce epilepsy-related stigma by addressing specific socio-cultural groups. Further research within a cross-cultural approach is recommended to deepen these findings.
癫痫患者面临着污名化问题,这影响着他们日常生活的诸多方面。尽管围绕癫痫患者的污名化现象已有大量记录,但其中的潜在机制,如文化刻板印象,仍有待探索。文化刻板印象是在文化背景中广泛共享的关于特定群体成员通常具有的属性的信念。这项在法国社会开展的研究有两个主要目标:1)界定与癫痫患者相关的文化刻板印象的内容;2)考察对癫痫的熟悉程度和了解程度如何影响这些刻板印象。为了探究这些刻板印象,我们对三个文化群体(n = 96)进行了自由联想任务:(1)普通人群,对癫痫的熟悉程度和了解程度较低(n = 39);(2)非癫痫专科的医疗专业人员,他们比普通人群对癫痫有更多的熟悉度和了解(n = 38);(3)癫痫专科的医疗专业人员,他们在这三个群体中对癫痫的熟悉程度和了解程度最高(n = 29)。所有参与者都拥有高等教育学历,以确保各群体之间有更同质化的社会文化背景。我们使用软件程序“IraMuTeQ”,分析了每个群体与“癫痫患者”相关的词汇的多样性。此外,我们还考察了每个群体中文化刻板印象的效价和典型性。结果显示,无论熟悉程度和了解程度如何,与癫痫相关的文化刻板印象总体上都是负面的。在整个样本中,与癫痫患者最典型的联想包括“疯狂”“着魔”“舌头”和“智力缺陷”。普通人群与非专科医疗专业人员有一些共同的文化刻板印象(如“光敏性”),而非专科专业人员与专科医疗专业人员有其他共同联想(如“智力缺陷”和“精神疾病”)。然而,普通人群的文化刻板印象与癫痫专科医疗专业人员的文化刻板印象之间没有重叠。与普通人群相比,与癫痫相关的刻板印象在医疗专业人员中似乎不太典型。下面将进一步讨论文化刻板印象与个人信念之间的这种区别。考虑文化刻板印象可能有助于通过针对特定的社会文化群体采取更有针对性和更有效的干预措施来减少与癫痫相关的污名化。建议采用跨文化方法进行进一步研究以深化这些发现。