Agoubi Lauren, Carvalho Melissa, Fewer Sara, Oke Rasheedat, Fabo Brice, Daya Leonid, Obiezu Fiona, Adeola Janet, Nteungue Boris A K, Ekane Yannick, Etoundi Alain Mballa, Juillard Catherine
Harborview Injury Prevention and Research Center, University of Washington, Seattle, Washington, USA
Program for the Advancement of Surgical Equity (PASE), Department of Surgery, University of California, Los Angeles, California, USA.
BMJ Glob Health. 2024 Dec 15;9(12):e014730. doi: 10.1136/bmjgh-2023-014730.
Surgical diseases contribute substantially to death and disability in Cameroon. Strategic planning for surgical, obstetric and anaesthesia (SOA) care in low-income and middle-income countries (LMICs) requires consideration of the policy environment in addition to the issue severity. We aimed at the current landscape of SOA care in Cameroon, incorporating a framework for political prioritisation.
A scoping review of published and grey literature was performed. Literature specific to Cameroon, published between 2010 and 2020 and written in either English or French, was included. Abstracts and full texts were screened for discussion of SOA policy context, care and delivery conditions, and issue characteristics. Data extraction and analysis were performed using the Shiffman and Smith framework for political prioritisation accounting for actors, ideas, political context and issue characteristics.
121 articles were included. By specialty, 83 articles were specific to surgery, 45 to obstetrics and 6 to anaesthesia. Policy environment was discussed by 20% (n=25) articles; 30% (n=37) discussed actor power; 22% (n=27) discussed ideas in SOA care and 93% discussed issue characteristics. Core challenges to political prioritisation of SOA care in Cameroon are limited actor support, a lack of consensus definitions, gaps in capacity and a need for systematic data collection on surgical diseases. Policy opportunities include leveraging existing multilateral partnerships to unify SOA actors, conducting national assessments of SOA care capacity, formalisation of task shifting to build capacity, defining essential SOA procedures, including surgical care in future health coverage, and defining and including SOA benchmarks in strategic planning.
Integrating a framework for political prioritisation into a situational analysis of SOA care is critical to understanding an LMIC's policy context and actors, in addition to issue severity. Such an approach can serve as a baseline for analysis in evidence-informed policy-making for SOA care, even in the absence of centralised, country-wide data.
外科疾病是喀麦隆死亡和残疾的主要原因。在低收入和中等收入国家(LMICs)进行外科、产科和麻醉(SOA)护理的战略规划,除了考虑问题的严重程度外,还需要考虑政策环境。我们旨在了解喀麦隆SOA护理的现状,并纳入一个政治优先排序框架。
对已发表和灰色文献进行了范围审查。纳入了2010年至2020年间发表的、以英语或法语撰写的喀麦隆特有的文献。对摘要和全文进行筛选,以讨论SOA政策背景、护理和提供条件以及问题特征。使用希夫曼和史密斯的政治优先排序框架进行数据提取和分析,该框架考虑了行为者、理念、政治背景和问题特征。
纳入了121篇文章。按专业划分,83篇文章专门针对外科,45篇针对产科,6篇针对麻醉。20%(n=25)的文章讨论了政策环境;30%(n=37)讨论了行为者的权力;22%(n=27)讨论了SOA护理中的理念,93%讨论了问题特征。喀麦隆SOA护理政治优先排序的核心挑战包括行为者支持有限、缺乏共识定义、能力差距以及需要系统收集外科疾病数据。政策机遇包括利用现有的多边伙伴关系统一SOA行为者、对SOA护理能力进行国家评估、将任务转移正式化以建设能力、定义基本的SOA程序、将外科护理纳入未来的健康覆盖范围以及在战略规划中定义并纳入SOA基准。
将政治优先排序框架纳入SOA护理的情境分析对于理解中低收入国家的政策背景和行为者以及问题的严重程度至关重要。即使在缺乏集中的全国性数据的情况下,这种方法也可以作为SOA护理循证决策分析的基线。