Pearce Emily Eidenier, Majid Alina, Brown Toniya, Shepherd Rowan Forbes, Rising Camella, Wilsnack Catherine, Thompson Ashley S, Gilkey Melissa B, Ribisl Kurt M, Lazard Allison J, Han Paul Kj, Werner-Lin Allison, Hutson Sadie P, Savage Sharon A
Clinical Genetics Branch, Division of Cancer Epidemiology and Genetics, National Cancer Institute, National Institutes of Health, Rockville, MD, United States.
Healthcare Delivery Research Program, National Cancer Institute, National Institutes of Health, Rockville, MD, United States.
JMIR Form Res. 2024 Dec 16;8:e64343. doi: 10.2196/64343.
Web-based information and social support are commonly used in rare disease communities where geographic dispersion and limited provider expertise complicate in-person support. We examined web-based resource use among caregivers of individuals with telomere biology disorders (TBDs), which are rare genetic conditions with long diagnostic odysseys and uncertain prognoses including multiorgan system cancer risk.
This study explored internet-based information-seeking and social support practices and perspectives of patients with TBDs and their caregivers.
Our qualitative descriptive study used semistructured interviews of patients with TBDs and caregivers. Data were transcribed verbatim and thematically analyzed by an interdisciplinary team.
A total of 32 adults completed interviews. Participant ages ranged from 27 to 74 years. The majority (n=28, 88%) were female, occupied multiple TBD roles (eg, patient and parent), and had undergone genetic testing. Most engaged in web-based information-seeking (n=29, 91%) and TBD-specific social media (n=26, 81%). Participants found web-based resources useful for information-seeking but reported privacy concerns and frustration with forming supportive relationships. Most participants described ambivalence toward web-based resource use, citing tensions between hunger for information versus distrust, empowerment versus overwhelm, disclosure versus privacy, and accessibility versus connection. Fluctuations in web-based support use arose from perceived harms, information saturation, or decreased relevance over the course of TBD illness experience.
Individuals with TBDs and their caregivers reported frequent use of web-based informational and emotional support. However, ambivalence about the benefits and liabilities of web-based resources and persistent medical uncertainty may impact the adoption of and adherence to web-based support among patients with TBD and caregivers. Our findings suggest web-based psychosocial support should target long-term and multifaceted informational and emotional needs, be user-initiated, be offered alongside in-person formats, provide expert-informed information, and be attentive to personal privacy and evolving support needs of the TBD community. This study suggests web-based resources will be most effective in the TBD context when they achieve the following features: (1) offer a variety of ways to engage (eg, active and passive), (2) provide privacy protections in moderated "safe spaces" designed for personal disclosure, (3) offer separate venues for informational versus emotional support, (4) combine web-based relationship formation with opportunities for in-person gathering, (5) provide information that is reliable, easy to access, and informed by medical professionals, (6) remain mindful of user distress, and (7) are responsive to variations in levels and types of engagement. Additionally, advocacy organizations may wish to avoid traditional social media platforms when designing safe spaces for web-based emotional support, instead pivoting to internet-based tools that minimize privacy threats and limit the perpetual public availability of shared information.
基于网络的信息和社会支持在罕见病群体中普遍使用,因为地域分散和医疗服务提供者专业知识有限,使得面对面的支持变得复杂。我们研究了端粒生物学障碍(TBD)患者的照顾者对基于网络资源的使用情况,TBD是一种罕见的遗传疾病,诊断过程漫长,预后不确定,包括多器官系统癌症风险。
本研究探讨了TBD患者及其照顾者基于互联网的信息寻求和社会支持实践及观点。
我们的定性描述性研究采用了对TBD患者及其照顾者的半结构化访谈。数据逐字转录,并由一个跨学科团队进行主题分析。
共有32名成年人完成了访谈。参与者年龄在27至74岁之间。大多数(n = 28,88%)为女性,担任多种TBD角色(如患者和家长),并进行了基因检测。大多数人参与基于网络的信息寻求(n = 29,91%)和特定于TBD的社交媒体(n = 26,81%)。参与者发现基于网络的资源对信息寻求有用,但报告了隐私问题以及在建立支持性关系方面的挫折感。大多数参与者描述了对基于网络资源使用的矛盾态度,指出在渴望信息与不信任、获得力量与不堪重负、披露与隐私、可及性与联系之间存在紧张关系。基于网络的支持使用的波动源于TBD疾病经历过程中感知到的危害、信息饱和或相关性降低。
TBD患者及其照顾者报告经常使用基于网络的信息和情感支持。然而,对基于网络资源的利弊的矛盾态度以及持续的医疗不确定性可能会影响TBD患者及其照顾者对基于网络支持的采用和坚持。我们的研究结果表明,基于网络的心理社会支持应针对长期和多方面的信息及情感需求,由用户发起,与面对面形式一起提供,提供专家提供的信息,并关注个人隐私和TBD群体不断变化的支持需求。本研究表明,基于网络的资源在TBD背景下最有效的时候应具备以下特征:(1)提供多种参与方式(如主动和被动);(2)在为个人披露设计的适度“安全空间”中提供隐私保护;(3)为信息支持和情感支持提供单独的场所;(4)将基于网络的关系形成与面对面聚会的机会相结合;(5)提供可靠、易于获取且由医学专业人员提供的信息;(6)关注用户的痛苦;(7)对参与程度和类型的变化做出响应。此外,倡导组织在设计基于网络的情感支持的安全空间时,可能希望避免使用传统社交媒体平台,转而采用能将隐私威胁降至最低并限制共享信息永久公开可用性的基于互联网的工具。