Lysophospholipids (LPLs) and host defense peptides (HDPs) are naturally occurring membrane-active agents that disrupt key membrane properties, including the hydrocarbon thickness, intrinsic curvature, and molecular packing. Although the membrane activity of these agents has been widely examined separately, their combined effects are largely unexplored. Here, we use experimental and computational tools to investigate how lysophosphatidylcholine (LPC) and lysophosphatidylethanolamine (LPE), an LPL of lower positive spontaneous curvature, influence the membrane activity of piscidin 1 (P1), an α-helical HDP from fish. Four membrane systems are probed: 75:25 C16:0-C18:1 PC (POPC)/C16:0-C18:1 phosphoglycerol (POPG), 50:25:25 POPC/POPG/16:0 LPC, 75:25 C16:0-C18:1 PE (POPE)/POPG, and 50:25:25 POPE/POPG/14:0 LPE. Dye leakage, circular dichroism, and NMR experiments demonstrate that while the presence of LPLs alone does not induce leakage-proficient defects, it boosts the permeabilization capability of P1, resulting in an efficacy order of POPC/POPG/16:0 LPC > POPE/POPG/14:0 LPE > POPC/POPG > POPE/POPG. This enhancement occurs without altering the membrane affinity and conformation of P1. Molecular dynamics simulations feature two types of asymmetric membranes to represent the imbalanced ("area stressed") and balanced ("area relaxed") distribution of lipids and peptides in the two leaflets. The simulations capture the membrane thinning effects of P1, LPC, and LPE, and the positive curvature strain imposed by both LPLs is reflected in the lateral pressure profiles. They also reveal a higher number of membrane defects for the P1/LPC than P1/LPE combination, congruent with the permeabilization experiments. Altogether, these results show that P1 and LPLs disrupt membranes in a concerted fashion, with LPC, the more disruptive LPL, boosting the permeabilization of P1 more than LPE. This mechanistic knowledge is relevant to understanding biological processes where multiple membrane-active agents such as HDPs and LPLs are involved.