Chau Leena W, Lou Hayami, Murphy Jill K, Nguyen Vu Cong, Small Will, Samji Hasina, O'Neil John
Faculty of Health Sciences, Simon Fraser University, Vancouver, Canada.
Interdisciplinary Health Program, St. Francis Xavier University, Antigonish, Canada.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2024 Dec 18;24(1):1563. doi: 10.1186/s12913-024-12036-2.
The global burden of mental illness is substantial, with depression impacting close to 300 million people worldwide. This has been exacerbated within the context of the COVID-19 pandemic. Yet, in many low- and middle-income countries including Vietnam, there is a substantial treatment gap, with many requiring mental health care unable to access it. Task-shifting is an evidence-based approach that seeks to address this gap by utilizing non-specialist providers to provide care. While there is a large body of literature exploring task-shifting, there is little that explores the client experience. This paper describes the facilitators and barriers impacting the client experience of a task-shifting supported self-management (SSM) intervention for depression in Vietnam. SSM involves a client workbook and supportive coaching by non-specialist providers.
This paper is situated within a randomized controlled trial that demonstrated the effectiveness of the SSM intervention in adult populations across eight provinces in Vietnam. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with a convenience sample of clients (recipients of the intervention) with depression caseness as measured by the Self-Report Questionnaire-20 depression screening measure, and providers (non-specialist "social collaborators") to explore SSM's acceptability and factors influencing participation and adherence. This paper presents the qualitative findings from an analysis of the interviews, focusing on the client perspective. Qualitative descriptive methods and thematic analysis were used.
Forty-five clients were interviewed. Sub-themes reported for the facilitators and benefits for the client experience of the SSM intervention were client-provider relationship building and family and community connections. Sub-themes reported for the barriers were clients' responsibilities, clients' health conditions, and consequences of stigma.
Due to challenges with sustaining and scaling up the in-person SSM intervention in Vietnam, the research team has pivoted to delivering the SSM intervention digitally through a smartphone-based app adapted from SSM, with direction from the Government of Vietnam. Findings from this study suggest that while digital interventions may support accessibility and convenience, they may neglect the critical human contact component of mental health care. Ultimately, a model that combines digital delivery with some form of human contact by a support person may be important.
精神疾病的全球负担十分沉重,抑郁症影响着全球近3亿人。在新冠疫情背景下,这一情况更加恶化。然而,在包括越南在内的许多低收入和中等收入国家,治疗差距巨大,许多需要心理健康护理的人无法获得相应服务。任务转移是一种循证方法,旨在通过利用非专科提供者提供护理来解决这一差距。虽然有大量文献探讨任务转移,但很少有研究探索服务对象的体验。本文描述了影响越南一项针对抑郁症的任务转移支持下的自我管理(SSM)干预措施服务对象体验的促进因素和障碍。SSM包括一本服务对象工作手册以及非专科提供者的支持性指导。
本文基于一项随机对照试验,该试验证明了SSM干预措施在越南八个省份的成年人群中的有效性。对通过《自评问卷-20》抑郁筛查量表测量为抑郁症患者的服务对象(干预措施的接受者)和提供者(非专科“社会协作者”)进行了便利抽样的半结构化访谈,以探讨SSM的可接受性以及影响参与和坚持的因素。本文呈现了对访谈进行分析得出的定性研究结果,重点关注服务对象的视角。采用了定性描述方法和主题分析法。
对45名服务对象进行了访谈。报告的关于SSM干预措施服务对象体验的促进因素和益处的子主题是服务对象与提供者关系的建立以及家庭和社区联系。报告的障碍子主题是服务对象的责任、服务对象的健康状况以及污名化的后果。
由于在越南维持和扩大面对面的SSM干预措施存在挑战,研究团队已转向通过一款基于智能手机的应用程序以数字方式提供SSM干预措施,该应用程序是根据SSM改编的,并在越南政府的指导下进行。本研究结果表明,虽然数字干预措施可能有助于提高可及性和便利性,但它们可能会忽视心理健康护理中至关重要的人际接触部分。最终,将数字交付与某种形式的由支持人员进行的人际接触相结合的模式可能很重要。