Mackie Andrew S, Gray Mandi, Chappell Alyssa, Dlusskaya Kira, Lightning Rick, Listener Larry, Crier Arrol, Dumigan-Jackson Barbara, Thomas Audrey, Graham Bonny, Littlechild Randy, Lightning Joshua, Johnson Azure, Rain Patricia, Cutarm Maxine, Oster Richard T
Department of Pediatrics, University of Alberta, Edmonton Clinic Health Academy, 11405-87 Avenue, Edmonton, AB, T6G 1C9, Canada.
Trent University, 1600 West Bank Drive, Peterborough, ON, Canada.
Int J Equity Health. 2024 Dec 18;23(1):268. doi: 10.1186/s12939-024-02343-9.
This study examined the experiences of Indigenous youth and young adults with pediatric onset chronic health conditions who had or were about to transition from pediatric to adult healthcare services. Transition is the process by which youth develop the knowledge and self-management skills needed to manage their health condition, ideally beginning around age 12-13 and continuing until the mid-20s. There is a growing body of literature on healthcare transition, but there is an absence of literature on Indigenous youth, who face additional barriers to accessing healthcare relative to non-Indigenous Canadians. The primary objective of this study was to identify the supports and barriers for Indigenous youth with childhood-onset chronic health conditions transitioning from pediatric to adult healthcare services.
The research was done in the province of Alberta, Canada, in collaboration with a Community Advisory Committee comprised of Indigenous healthcare providers, Elders and Knowledge Keepers and guided by a community-based participatory research approach. Semi-structured qualitative interviews (n = 46) were conducted with Indigenous youth, caregivers, and healthcare providers. There were three Talking Circles, two for youth (9 participants) and one for caregivers (6 participants). Three research assistants coded the transcripts thematically using NVivo. The key findings were presented to the Community Advisory Committee for feedback to validate the interpretation of the qualitative data.
The thematic findings include: (1) systemic inequalities exacerbate gaps in healthcare; (2) intergenerational trauma created unique barriers for Indigenous youth; (3) long-term relationships with care providers as a protective factor; (4) the incorporation of Indigenous worldviews into healthcare services to aid transition; and (5) assuming new responsibilities as an adult. The participants provided recommendations to improve healthcare service delivery including the need for Indigenous transition supports in community and improving education for healthcare practitioners about transition and Indigenous worldviews.
This study demonstrates the complexity of the transition experience for Indigenous youth with pediatric onset chronic health conditions. The identified barriers to successful transition could be addressed through systems level changes and the development of Indigenous specific transition support services. Such approaches need to be Indigenous-led and incorporate Indigenous culture, language, and teachings.
本研究调查了患有儿童期慢性健康状况的原住民青年和年轻人的经历,他们已经或即将从儿科医疗服务过渡到成人医疗服务。过渡是指年轻人培养管理自身健康状况所需的知识和自我管理技能的过程,理想情况下从12 - 13岁左右开始,一直持续到25岁左右。关于医疗过渡的文献越来越多,但关于原住民青年的文献却很缺乏,相对于非原住民加拿大人,他们在获得医疗服务方面面临更多障碍。本研究的主要目的是确定患有儿童期慢性健康状况的原住民青年从儿科医疗服务过渡到成人医疗服务的支持因素和障碍。
该研究在加拿大艾伯塔省进行,与一个由原住民医疗服务提供者、长者和知识守护者组成的社区咨询委员会合作,并以基于社区的参与性研究方法为指导。对原住民青年、照顾者和医疗服务提供者进行了半结构化定性访谈(n = 46)。举办了三个交流圈,两个面向青年(9名参与者),一个面向照顾者(6名参与者)。三名研究助理使用NVivo对访谈记录进行主题编码。关键研究结果提交给社区咨询委员会以获取反馈,以验证定性数据的解读。
主题研究结果包括:(1)系统性不平等加剧了医疗保健方面的差距;(2)代际创伤给原住民青年带来了独特的障碍;(3)与医疗服务提供者的长期关系是一个保护因素;(4)将原住民世界观纳入医疗服务以促进过渡;(5)成年后承担新责任。参与者提出了改善医疗服务提供的建议,包括需要在社区提供原住民过渡支持,以及提高医疗从业者对过渡和原住民世界观的教育。
本研究表明了患有儿童期慢性健康状况的原住民青年过渡经历的复杂性。可以通过系统层面的变革和开发针对原住民的特定过渡支持服务来解决已确定的成功过渡的障碍。此类方法需要由原住民主导,并纳入原住民文化、语言和教义。