Lee HaEun, Fiseha Neyat, Bateisibwa Jordan, Moyer Cheryl A, Greenberg Joshua, Maffioli Elisa
Department of Systems, Populations, and Leadership , University of Michigan School of Nursing, Ann Arbor, Michigan, USA.
University of Michigan Medical School, Ann Arbor, Michigan, USA.
BMC Public Health. 2024 Dec 18;24(1):3526. doi: 10.1186/s12889-024-21025-3.
Lack of accountability within healthcare systems contributes to suboptimal healthcare quality and ultimately poor health outcomes, especially in low-income countries. In Uganda, our research team implemented a pilot project of quarterly health accountability meetings between community members and their local political leaders to discuss healthcare needs and strategies for quality improvement. In this study, we examine the community members' understanding and perceptions of the health accountability meetings, as well as the perceived impact of the meetings on local healthcare services and community life.
We conducted a total of 12 focus group discussions (FGDs), half with men and half with women, in November 2022 across six randomly chosen communities out of the ten communities where health accountability meetings were held. We audio taped, transcribed, and translated all FGDs into English. We collected data on demographics, understanding of the meetings, and perceived changes within healthcare services and the community from 111 participants. Two researchers analyzed the data using an inductive thematic approach, generating five themes.
We found the following themes: (1) increased inclusivity and promotion of bidirectional communication; (2) increased understanding of patient rights and practicing of collective empowerment by the community; (3) improved provider behavior; (4) enhanced relationships among politicians, community members, and healthcare providers; and (5) identified needs for future improvements.
Through this qualitative study, we found that the community members perceived the accountability meetings as beneficial in improving the local healthcare services and community life. The study demonstrates the need to prioritize the voices of local communities in efforts to address the accountability gaps, as well as the potential for utilizing the relationship between community members and politicians to address accountability shortfalls in other governmental functions beyond healthcare.
N/A.
医疗体系缺乏问责制会导致医疗质量欠佳,最终造成健康状况不佳,在低收入国家尤其如此。在乌干达,我们的研究团队开展了一个试点项目,即社区成员与其当地政治领导人每季度举行一次健康问责会议,以讨论医疗需求和质量改进策略。在本研究中,我们考察了社区成员对健康问责会议的理解和看法,以及会议对当地医疗服务和社区生活的感知影响。
2022年11月,我们在举行健康问责会议的10个社区中随机选取了6个社区,总共进行了12次焦点小组讨论(FGD),男女各半。我们对所有FGD进行了录音、转录,并翻译成英文。我们收集了111名参与者的人口统计学数据、对会议的理解,以及对医疗服务和社区内感知变化的数据。两名研究人员采用归纳主题法对数据进行分析,得出了五个主题。
我们发现了以下主题:(1)增强包容性并促进双向沟通;(2)社区对患者权利的理解增加并践行集体赋权;(3)改善提供者行为;(4)加强政治家、社区成员和医疗服务提供者之间的关系;(5)确定未来改进的需求。
通过这项定性研究,我们发现社区成员认为问责会议有利于改善当地医疗服务和社区生活。该研究表明,在努力解决问责差距时,需要优先考虑当地社区的声音,以及利用社区成员与政治家之间的关系来解决医疗保健以外其他政府职能中的问责不足问题的潜力。
无。