Claus Jacqueline J, Berghout Bernhard B P, Box Camiel V J, Licher Silvan, Roozenbeek Bob, Ikram M Kamran, Wolters Frank J
Department of Epidemiology, Erasmus MC, University Medical Centre Rotterdam, Wytemaweg 80, Rotterdam, CA, 3015, the Netherlands.
Department of Radiology & Nuclear Medicine, Erasmus MC, University Medical Centre Rotterdam, Wytemaweg 80, Rotterdam, CA, 3015, the Netherlands.
BMC Public Health. 2024 Dec 18;24(1):3512. doi: 10.1186/s12889-024-20960-5.
Urgent medical treatment is crucial after stroke and transient ischemic attack (TIA), but hindered by extensive prehospital delays. Public education campaigns based on FAST (Face-Arm-Speech-Time) have improved response after major stroke, but not minor stroke and TIA. We aimed to provide strategies to improve public education on a national level, by characterizing TIA and stroke symptoms in a population-based cohort, and extrapolating findings to the general Dutch population.
We included all patients with first-ever stroke or TIA from 2002-2016 in the population-based Rotterdam Study (N = 17,931). We determined the prevalence of focal neurological symptoms and their combinations by event severity (i.e., TIA, minor stroke [National Institutes of Health Stroke Scale (NIHSS) 0-3], and major stroke [NIHSS > 3]). We assessed sensitivity of the FAST test for TIA and stroke, and estimated specificity using survey data on the incidence of focal neurological symptoms of non-vascular origin from the same source population. Finally, we determined the diagnostic value of adding visual symptoms and vertigo to the FAST test.
Of all 900 patients (mean age: 77.6 years, 57.2% women), 409 (45.4%) had a TIA, 254 (28.2%) had minor stroke, and 237 (26.3%) had major stroke. At least one FAST symptom was present in 233/237 (98.3%) of patients with major stroke, compared to 186/254 (73.2%) patients with minor stroke, and 250/402 (62.2%) with TIA. Minor strokes and TIA not captured by the FAST test most commonly involved visual symptoms (52.7%), dizziness/vertigo (19.5%), disturbed coordination (19.1%), and sensory disturbance (18.2%). Sensitivity of FAST for TIA/minor stroke increased from 66.4 to 80.8% with the addition of visual symptoms, and to 86.1% with further incorporation of dizziness/vertigo, albeit with a > 40% increase in the number of false positive events. Nearly all patients with major stroke (97.5%) experienced a combination of multiple symptoms, whereas 58.9% of patients with TIA and 26.4% of those with minor stroke reported only a single symptom.
In contrast to major stroke, sensitivity of the FAST test is limited to around 65% for TIA and minor stroke in a population-based setting. Sensitivity increases by incorporating visual symptoms and vertigo, but this comes with a large number of false positives. Findings of this study may favor a focus on the importance of isolated or transient symptoms, rather than additional symptoms, in future stroke public education campaigns.
中风和短暂性脑缺血发作(TIA)后紧急医疗救治至关重要,但受到院前长时间延误的阻碍。基于FAST(脸-臂-言语-时间)的公众教育活动改善了重大中风后的反应,但对轻微中风和TIA无效。我们旨在通过在基于人群的队列中描述TIA和中风症状,并将研究结果外推至荷兰普通人群,提供在国家层面改善公众教育的策略。
我们纳入了2002年至2016年基于人群的鹿特丹研究中所有首次发生中风或TIA的患者(N = 17,931)。我们根据事件严重程度(即TIA、轻微中风[美国国立卫生研究院卒中量表(NIHSS)0 - 3]和重大中风[NIHSS>3])确定局灶性神经症状及其组合的患病率。我们评估了FAST测试对TIA和中风的敏感性,并使用来自同一源人群的非血管性起源局灶性神经症状发生率的调查数据估计特异性。最后,我们确定了在FAST测试中增加视觉症状和眩晕的诊断价值。
在所有900例患者(平均年龄:77.6岁,57.2%为女性)中,409例(45.4%)患有TIA,254例(28.2%)患有轻微中风,237例(26.3%)患有重大中风。237例重大中风患者中有233例(98.3%)至少出现一种FAST症状,相比之下,254例轻微中风患者中有186例(73.2%),402例TIA患者中有250例(62.2%)。FAST测试未捕捉到的轻微中风和TIA最常涉及视觉症状(52.7%)、头晕/眩晕(19.5%)、协调障碍(19.1%)和感觉障碍(18.2%)。添加视觉症状后,FAST对TIA/轻微中风的敏感性从66.4%提高到80.8%,进一步纳入头晕/眩晕后提高到86.1%,尽管假阳性事件数量增加了>40%。几乎所有重大中风患者(97.5%)都经历了多种症状的组合,而58.9%的TIA患者和26.4%的轻微中风患者仅报告了单一症状。
与重大中风相比,在基于人群的环境中,FAST测试对TIA和轻微中风的敏感性限制在约65%。纳入视觉症状和眩晕可提高敏感性,但会带来大量假阳性。本研究结果可能有利于在未来的中风公众教育活动中关注孤立或短暂症状而非附加症状的重要性。