Ewen Alana M, Hawkins Jaclynn M, Kloss Katherine A, Sengupta Srijani, Burgess Hannah, Nwankwo Robin, Funnell Martha, Mitchell Jamie, Piatt Gretchen
Department of Behavioral and Community Health, School of Public Health, University of Maryland, 4200 Valley Dr., Suite 1234, College Park, MD, 20742, USA.
School of Social Work, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2024 Dec 18;24(1):1612. doi: 10.1186/s12913-024-11884-2.
Black men are more likely to be diagnosed with type 2 diabetes (T2D) compared to non-Hispanic White men, especially those over 55 years of age. Although there is ample evidence around the efficacy of peer-led diabetes self-management and support (PLDSMS) programs in improving diabetes health outcomes, Black men living with T2D experience several barriers to meaningful participation in peer-led programs and program developers face barriers to implementation. This qualitative study aimed to identify perspectives from collaborators on barriers and facilitators that impact the implementation of a PLDSMS intervention for older Black men with T2D.
Qualitative data were collected as part of the Michigan Men's Diabetes Project. We used the Tailored Implementation in Chronic Diseases (TICD) Checklist to construct the semi-structured interview guide. TICD domains served as themes. Codes were later generated as a team (N = 3) from chunks of related text. Eight 1-on-1 semi-structured interviews (two researchers, three peer leaders, one community collaborator, two certified diabetes care and education specialists) were conducted between April 13-22, 2022 via Zoom. We engaged in thematic content analysis and used the rigorous and accelerated data reduction (RADaR) technique and Rapid analysis.
Themes included guideline factors; individual collaborator factors; patient factors; professional interactions; incentives and resources; capacity for organizational change; and use of technology. Guidelines for implementing a PLDSMS program for Black men with T2D are lacking. For effective implementation, collaborators need interpersonal and session facilitation skills, flexibility, and cultural awareness. Although Black men with T2D may initially be apprehensive about participating in a PLDSMS program due to lack of knowledge, masculine norms, and stigma, these programs offer a safe space, a sense of brotherhood, and transparency. Having a physician champion is key in supporting organizational changes needed to implement PLDSMS programs in health systems, particularly as PLDSMS is not currently a billable service.
The PLDSMS program is culturally relevant in engaging older Black men with T2D. In addition to building trust among participants, successful development and implementation of a peer support program requires flexibility and tailored communication strategies. Findings can be used to inform future iterations of PLDSMS programs.
与非西班牙裔白人男性相比,黑人男性被诊断出患有2型糖尿病(T2D)的可能性更高,尤其是55岁以上的男性。尽管有充分证据表明同伴主导的糖尿病自我管理与支持(PLDSMS)项目在改善糖尿病健康结局方面具有成效,但患有T2D的黑人男性在切实参与同伴主导项目方面面临诸多障碍,项目开发者在实施过程中也面临障碍。这项定性研究旨在确定合作者对于影响为患有T2D的老年黑人男性实施PLDSMS干预措施的障碍和促进因素的看法。
定性数据作为密歇根男性糖尿病项目的一部分收集。我们使用慢性病定制实施(TICD)清单构建半结构化访谈指南。TICD领域作为主题。代码随后由一个团队(N = 3)从相关文本块中生成。2022年4月13日至22日期间,通过Zoom进行了八次一对一的半结构化访谈(两名研究人员、三名同伴领袖、一名社区合作者、两名认证糖尿病护理和教育专家)。我们进行了主题内容分析,并使用了严格加速数据缩减(RADaR)技术和快速分析。
主题包括指南因素;个体合作者因素;患者因素;专业互动;激励措施和资源;组织变革能力;以及技术使用。缺乏针对患有T2D的黑人男性实施PLDSMS项目的指南。为有效实施,合作者需要人际和会议促进技能、灵活性和文化意识。尽管患有T2D的黑人男性最初可能因缺乏知识、男性规范和耻辱感而对参与PLDSMS项目有所顾虑,但这些项目提供了一个安全的空间、兄弟情谊和透明度。有医生支持是在卫生系统中实施PLDSMS项目所需支持组织变革的关键,特别是因为PLDSMS目前不是一项可计费服务。
PLDSMS项目在吸引患有T2D的老年黑人男性方面具有文化相关性。除了在参与者之间建立信任外,成功开发和实施同伴支持项目需要灵活性和量身定制的沟通策略。研究结果可用于为PLDSMS项目的未来迭代提供信息。