Roldán-Ruiz Alberto, Bailón-Cerezo Javier, Torres-Lacomba María
Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences, Physiotherapy and Nursing Department, University of Alcalá, Madrid, Spain.
School of Physiotherapy, Faculty of Health Sciences, Universidad Francisco de Vitoria, Madrid, Spain.
J Man Manip Ther. 2025 Jun;33(3):253-261. doi: 10.1080/10669817.2024.2443134. Epub 2024 Dec 20.
Determining the prevalence of different shoulder subclassification-based diagnoses using a defined exclusion-type diagnostic algorithm. Analyzing the relationships between cervical contribution and other shoulder diagnoses.
A proposal of a shoulder pain diagnosis based on functional subclassification was carried out in all subjects. The included diagnoses were cervical contribution, acromioclavicular joint pain, stiff shoulder, atraumatic unstable shoulder, rotator cuff-related shoulder pain, and 'Others'. Each diagnosis was based on a defined exclusion-type diagnostic algorithm. Cervical contribution was considered if a > 30% shoulder symptom modification in pain intensity was recorded after a cervical spine screening. Since a > 30% change in symptoms does not definitively indicate a categorical diagnosis, cervical contribution was presumed to potentially coexist with other diagnostic labels in these cases. If there was a complete (100%) resolution of shoulder symptoms after the cervical spine screening, cervical contribution was deemed the sole diagnosis.
Sixty subjects were analyzed. Rotator cuff-related shoulder pain was the most prevalent diagnosis (36.7%, = 22), followed by stiff shoulder, being present in 30% ( = 18) of subjects. Cervical contribution (13.3%, = 8), atraumatic unstable shoulder (11.7%, = 7), others (6.7%, = 4) and acromioclavicular joint pain (1,7%, = 1) completed the results. In patients diagnosed with rotator cuff-related shoulder pain, cervical contribution coexisted in 71,4% of them. Thus, a statistically significant association between cervical contribution and rotator cuff-related shoulder pain was found ( = 0,002). This association was not observed in any of the other diagnoses.
DISCUSSIONS/CONCLUSIONS: Rotator cuff-related shoulder pain was the most prevalent diagnosis, followed by stiff shoulder and cervical contribution. Cervical contribution may coexist with other diagnoses or even be considered as a unique diagnosis itself. Patients diagnosed with rotator cuff-related shoulder pain are more likely to have cervical contribution.
使用定义的排除型诊断算法确定基于不同肩部亚分类诊断的患病率。分析颈部因素与其他肩部诊断之间的关系。
对所有受试者进行基于功能亚分类的肩部疼痛诊断建议。纳入的诊断包括颈部因素、肩锁关节疼痛、肩周炎、非创伤性不稳定肩、肩袖相关肩部疼痛和“其他”。每种诊断均基于定义的排除型诊断算法。如果在颈椎筛查后记录到疼痛强度的肩部症状改善超过30%,则考虑颈部因素。由于症状变化超过30%并不能明确表明分类诊断,因此在这些情况下,颈部因素可能与其他诊断标签共存。如果颈椎筛查后肩部症状完全(100%)缓解,则颈部因素被视为唯一诊断。
分析了60名受试者。肩袖相关肩部疼痛是最常见的诊断(36.7%,n = 22),其次是肩周炎,在30%(n = 18)的受试者中存在。颈部因素(13.3%,n = 8)、非创伤性不稳定肩(11.7%,n = 7)、其他(6.7%,n = 4)和肩锁关节疼痛(1.7%,n = 1)完成了结果。在诊断为肩袖相关肩部疼痛的患者中,71.4%存在颈部因素。因此,发现颈部因素与肩袖相关肩部疼痛之间存在统计学上的显著关联(p = 0.002)。在任何其他诊断中均未观察到这种关联。
讨论/结论:肩袖相关肩部疼痛是最常见的诊断,其次是肩周炎和颈部因素。颈部因素可能与其他诊断共存,甚至本身被视为唯一诊断。诊断为肩袖相关肩部疼痛的患者更有可能存在颈部因素。