Walker P R, Marshall A J, Farr S, Bauminger B, Walters G, Barritt D W
Br Heart J. 1985 Mar;53(3):276-82. doi: 10.1136/hrt.53.3.276.
The effects of abrupt withdrawal of atenolol, a long acting cardioselective beta blocker, were studied in 20 patients with severe stable angina pectoris admitted to hospital for coronary arteriography. During the 144 hour postwithdrawal period no serious coronary events occurred. Mean and maximal daily heart rates rose steadily for at least 120 hours. No important arrhythmias were noted on ambulatory electrocardiographic monitoring. Treadmill exercise testing at 120 hours showed little reduction in the times to angina, ST depression, and maximal exercise when compared with those recorded at 24 hours. This deterioration was small when contrasted with the improvements in these indices produced by atenolol treatment in a similar group of patients not admitted to hospital. No change in catecholamine concentrations or acceleration of the heart rate response to exercise occurred after atenolol withdrawal, suggesting that rebound adrenergic stimulation or hypersensitivity was absent or insignificant. Catastrophic coronary events after beta blockade withdrawal (the beta blockade withdrawal syndrome) have occurred almost exclusively in patients taking propranolol, many of whom had unstable angina at the time of withdrawal. This study showed that in patients with stable angina, even when severe, the abrupt withdrawal of atenolol can be expected to result in only minor clinical consequences. The risk to any patient of so called rebound events after withdrawal of beta blockade seems to be related to both the clinical setting and the agent being used.
对20例因冠状动脉造影而入院的重度稳定型心绞痛患者,研究了长效心脏选择性β受体阻滞剂阿替洛尔突然停药的影响。在停药后的144小时内,未发生严重的冠状动脉事件。平均每日心率和最大心率至少持续120小时稳步上升。动态心电图监测未发现重要心律失常。与24小时记录的数据相比,120小时时的平板运动试验显示心绞痛发作时间、ST段压低和最大运动量减少不多。与未入院的类似患者组中阿替洛尔治疗所产生的这些指标的改善相比,这种恶化程度较小。阿替洛尔停药后,儿茶酚胺浓度未改变,运动时心率反应也未加速,提示不存在或仅有轻微的反跳性肾上腺素能刺激或超敏反应。β受体阻滞剂停药后发生的灾难性冠状动脉事件(β受体阻滞剂停药综合征)几乎仅发生在服用普萘洛尔的患者中,其中许多患者在停药时患有不稳定型心绞痛。本研究表明,对于稳定型心绞痛患者,即使病情严重,突然停用阿替洛尔预计只会导致轻微的临床后果。β受体阻滞剂停药后所谓反跳事件对任何患者的风险似乎与临床情况和所使用的药物均有关。