Quek Fang Fang
Clinical Education, Edinburgh Medical School, The University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, GBR.
Cureus. 2024 Dec 18;16(12):e75919. doi: 10.7759/cureus.75919. eCollection 2024 Dec.
Anatomy education, which forms the cornerstone of today's medical education, has traditionally centered on cadaveric dissections and prosections as its core teaching methods. However, these methods present with challenges, including student anxiety, nausea, and limited cadaver availability. Recent advancements in digital technologies have led to the proliferation of innovative learning tools, introducing novel and transformative approaches to enhance anatomy education. While numerous studies explore the potential applications of innovative technologies in anatomy education, few studies have examined their current application in anatomy teaching for undergraduate medical students. This gap in the literature is significant, as understanding the usability and acceptance of digital tools in anatomy teaching is crucial for ensuring that students receive high-quality education. To address this, a comprehensive review was undertaken to explore the breadth of research activity in this field, exploring the integration of digital technologies in anatomy teaching. This review aimed to address the research question: "How are digital technologies currently being used in the delivery of anatomy teaching in undergraduate medical education?". A systematic search was performed across multiple databases including PubMed, MEDLINE, Education Resources Information Center (ERIC), Embase, Scopus, and Web of Science, with studies screened using Covidence (Veritas Health Innovation, Melbourne, Australia), a web-based software platform. Eligible studies were systematically reviewed and data extracted and organised, with findings presented graphically, accompanied by descriptive narratives. Our findings indicate that while innovative digital tools are increasingly being adopted, many medical schools continue to rely predominantly on traditional cadaver-based methods for anatomy teaching. Only a limited number of institutions have fully integrated digital technologies into their teaching practices. Additionally, traditional approaches, such as cadaveric dissections and prosections, remain the preferred choice among students for learning anatomy. A commonly reported limitation of digital tools is their difficulty in effectively conveying spatial relationships between anatomical structures, a critical component in anatomy learning. Despite this, recent studies have revealed that students and educators increasingly value multimodal approaches that combine traditional cadaver-based teaching methods with digital tools to enhance anatomy learning. This review provides valuable insights into how digital technology is currently being utilised in anatomy teaching for undergraduate medical students. We found that while various innovative pedagogical approaches have been adopted in anatomy teaching, traditional methods such as cadaveric dissections and prosections remain the most preferred by students. While digital technology is increasingly being used to complement anatomical education, modern anatomy teaching currently adopts an integrated and multimodal approach, utilising various pedagogical methods to enhance anatomy learning. It is therefore essential that educators recognise that no single pedagogical approach suits all students and a combination of various modalities is often required to meet diverse learning needs in anatomy teaching.
解剖学教育是当今医学教育的基石,传统上一直以尸体解剖和局部解剖作为核心教学方法。然而,这些方法面临着诸多挑战,包括学生的焦虑、恶心以及尸体供应有限等问题。数字技术的最新进展促使创新学习工具大量涌现,为加强解剖学教育引入了新颖且具有变革性的方法。虽然众多研究探讨了创新技术在解剖学教育中的潜在应用,但很少有研究考察其在本科医学生解剖学教学中的实际应用情况。文献中的这一空白十分显著,因为了解数字工具在解剖学教学中的可用性和接受度对于确保学生接受高质量教育至关重要。为解决这一问题,我们进行了一项全面综述,以探究该领域的研究活动广度,探讨数字技术在解剖学教学中的整合情况。本综述旨在回答以下研究问题:“数字技术目前在本科医学教育的解剖学教学中是如何应用的?”我们在多个数据库中进行了系统检索,包括PubMed、MEDLINE、教育资源信息中心(ERIC)、Embase、Scopus和科学网,使用基于网络的软件平台Covidence(澳大利亚墨尔本的Veritas Health Innovation公司)对研究进行筛选。对符合条件的研究进行了系统综述,提取并整理了数据,研究结果以图表形式呈现,并伴有描述性叙述。我们的研究结果表明,虽然创新数字工具的采用越来越多,但许多医学院校在解剖学教学中仍主要依赖传统的基于尸体的方法。只有少数机构将数字技术完全融入了他们的教学实践中。此外,尸体解剖和局部解剖等传统方法仍是学生学习解剖学的首选。数字工具一个普遍被报道的局限性在于,它们难以有效传达解剖结构之间的空间关系,而这是解剖学学习中的一个关键要素。尽管如此,最近的研究表明,学生和教育工作者越来越重视将传统的基于尸体的教学方法与数字工具相结合的多模态方法,以加强解剖学学习。本综述为数字技术目前在本科医学生解剖学教学中的应用提供了有价值的见解。我们发现,虽然解剖学教学中采用了各种创新教学方法,但尸体解剖和局部解剖等传统方法仍是学生最喜欢的。虽然数字技术越来越多地被用于辅助解剖学教育,但现代解剖学教学目前采用的是一种综合的多模态方法,利用各种教学方法来加强解剖学学习。因此,教育工作者必须认识到,没有一种单一的教学方法适合所有学生,通常需要结合多种模式来满足解剖学教学中多样化的学习需求。