Eisman Andria B, Martin Jeffrey, Hasson Rebecca E, Kilbourne Amy M
Division of Kinesiology, Health and Sport Studies, College of Education, Wayne State University, Detroit, Michigan, USA.
Center for Health and Community Impact, Wayne State University, Detroit, Michigan, USA.
J Sch Health. 2024 Dec;94(12):1185-1195. doi: 10.1111/josh.13539. Epub 2024 Dec 25.
Comprehensive health education in schools can effectively prevent drug use and related outcomes, but successful implementation remains challenging. Contextual determinants, including intervention-setting compatibility, focus on the intervention, available resources, and leadership support, influence implementation success. This study investigates the impact of multilevel contextual determinants on Michigan Model for Health: (MMH) curriculum fidelity.
High school health teachers across Michigan (N = 171) participated in an MMH implementation survey. We used structural equation modeling to investigate the relative contributions of contextual determinants to implementation fidelity while also permitting the determinant factors to covary.
The models demonstrate a good fit with the data (structural: X = 51, df: 34, p = 0.03; RMSEA: 0.06, 95% CI: 0.02, 0.08; CFI: 0.98). Results indicate that the context latent factors individually were associated with fidelity. Examined together, we found significant covariance between the latent factors, but only resources predicted fidelity.
IMPLICATIONS FOR SCHOOL HEALTH POLICY, PRACTICE, AND EQUITY: School health policy and practice benefit from sufficient resources to support prevention curriculum implementation. Insufficient resources exacerbate existing barriers in low-resource communities, leading to unequal intervention implementation and widening health disparities.
Our results indicate that while contextual determinants are interrelated, sufficient resources are foundational to successful implementation.
学校全面健康教育能有效预防药物使用及相关后果,但成功实施仍具挑战性。情境决定因素,包括干预设置的兼容性、对干预的关注、可用资源和领导支持,会影响实施的成功。本研究调查多层次情境决定因素对密歇根健康模式(MMH)课程保真度的影响。
密歇根州的高中健康教师(N = 171)参与了一项MMH实施情况调查。我们使用结构方程模型来研究情境决定因素对实施保真度的相对贡献,同时也允许决定因素之间存在协变关系。
模型与数据拟合良好(结构:χ² = 51,自由度:34,p = 0.03;RMSEA:0.06,95%置信区间:0.02,0.08;CFI:0.98)。结果表明,情境潜在因素各自与保真度相关。综合考察发现,潜在因素之间存在显著协变关系,但只有资源能预测保真度。
对学校健康政策、实践和公平性的启示:学校健康政策和实践受益于足够的资源来支持预防课程的实施。资源不足会加剧资源匮乏社区现有的障碍,导致干预实施不平等,健康差距扩大。
我们的结果表明,虽然情境决定因素相互关联,但足够的资源是成功实施的基础。