Iqbal Saman, Khan Imran Ahmad, Khan Maliha Khalid, Ain Qurat-Ul-, Arif Hifza, Bukhari Komal Ammar, Bibi Rukhsana, Batool Urwa, Shahzad Mahnoor, Saad Tehreem
Ali-Ul-Murtaza, Department of Rehabilitation Sciences, Muhammad Institute of Medical and Allied Sciences, Multan, PAK.
Department of Pharmacy, Muhammad Nawaz Sharif University of Agriculture, Multan, PAK.
Cureus. 2024 Nov 25;16(11):e74382. doi: 10.7759/cureus.74382. eCollection 2024 Nov.
Background Given the increasing incidence and severity of knee osteoarthritis (OA), it is crucial to investigate and refine therapeutic approaches. Aim The objective of this study is to evaluate the effectiveness and potential synergistic effects of proprioceptive exercises combined with Mulligan traction straight leg raise (MT-SLR) in treating OA. This includes improving symptoms such as functional mobility, pain reduction, and relevant serological markers, highlighting the potential of this approach to enhance overall patient outcomes. Methods A pragmatic, community-based, parallel-group, double-blinded, randomized clinical trial was conducted from August 2023 to March 2024. A probability convenience sampling technique was used to calculate the sample size. A total of 130 pre-diagnosed OA patients were randomly assigned to three groups via the lottery method. Group A received proprioceptive exercises, group B received the MT-SLR, and group C received both proprioceptive exercises and MT-SLR. The Pain Catastrophizing Scale (PCS), Numerical Pain Rating Scale, Western Ontario and McMaster University Osteoarthritis Index (WOMAC), erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR), flexion, CRP, bone electrolytes in blood (calcium, magnesium, and phosphorus), and X-rays were used to quantify pain, stiffness, functional activities, biochemical parameters, and radiographic findings at baseline and after the 24th session. Data were analyzed using IBM SPSS Statistics for Windows, Version 23.0 (Released 2015; IBM Corp., Armonk, NY, USA), with a p-value of <0.05 considered statistically significant. Results Out of the 130 participants, 126 were analyzed at the 24th session, comprising 50 males and 76 females. After 24 sessions, Group C (combined therapy) exhibited the most significant improvements across all parameters (p = 0.000), including flexion range of motion, WOMAC Pain, activities of daily living, stiffness, and PCS, outperforming both Group A (p = 0.011) and Group B (p = 0.005). Group C also demonstrated the greatest reductions in ESR (p < 0.001), CRP (p < 0.001), and IL-6 (p < 0.001), along with the highest improvements in calcium, magnesium, and phosphorus levels (p < 0.005). X-ray assessments revealed that Group C had the most notable joint space recovery, while Group B showed no changes. Conclusions In the treatment of knee OA, proprioceptive exercises have been found to be more effective than the MT-SLR stretch. Given the rising prevalence and severity of knee OA, this study emphasizes the need to explore and refine treatment strategies. The findings indicate that combining MT-SLR with proprioceptive exercises yields superior results compared to either intervention alone. The group receiving the combined therapy showed the most significant improvements across several key measures, including functional mobility, pain reduction, and relevant serological markers, highlighting the potential of this approach to enhance overall patient outcomes. The notable differences in performance between the treatment groups suggest that a more comprehensive, integrative approach to knee OA could lead to better management outcomes.
背景 鉴于膝关节骨关节炎(OA)的发病率和严重程度不断增加,研究和完善治疗方法至关重要。目的 本研究的目的是评估本体感觉训练结合Mulligan牵引直腿抬高(MT-SLR)治疗OA的有效性和潜在协同作用。这包括改善功能活动能力、减轻疼痛等症状以及相关血清学指标,突出这种方法改善患者整体预后的潜力。方法 2023年8月至2024年3月进行了一项实用的、基于社区的、平行组、双盲、随机临床试验。采用概率便利抽样技术计算样本量。通过抽签法将130例预先诊断为OA的患者随机分为三组。A组接受本体感觉训练,B组接受MT-SLR,C组接受本体感觉训练和MT-SLR。使用疼痛灾难化量表(PCS)、数字疼痛评分量表、西安大略和麦克马斯特大学骨关节炎指数(WOMAC)、红细胞沉降率(ESR)、屈曲度、CRP、血液中的骨电解质(钙、镁和磷)以及X线检查来量化基线和第24次治疗后的疼痛、僵硬、功能活动、生化参数和影像学表现。使用IBM SPSS Statistics for Windows 23.0版(2015年发布;IBM公司,美国纽约州阿蒙克)进行数据分析,p值<0.05被认为具有统计学意义。结果 在130名参与者中,第24次治疗时对126人进行了分析,其中男性50人,女性76人。24次治疗后,C组(联合治疗)在所有参数上均表现出最显著的改善(p = 0.000),包括运动屈曲范围、WOMAC疼痛、日常生活活动、僵硬程度和PCS,优于A组(p = 0.011)和B组(p = 0.005)。C组还显示ESR(p < 0.001)、CRP(p < 0.001)和IL-6(p < 0.001)的降低幅度最大,同时钙、镁和磷水平的改善程度最高(p < 0.005)。X线评估显示C组关节间隙恢复最明显,而B组无变化。结论 在膝关节OA的治疗中,已发现本体感觉训练比MT-SLR拉伸更有效。鉴于膝关节OA的患病率和严重程度不断上升,本研究强调需要探索和完善治疗策略。研究结果表明,与单独的任何一种干预相比,将MT-SLR与本体感觉训练相结合能产生更好的效果。接受联合治疗的组在包括功能活动能力、减轻疼痛和相关血清学指标等几个关键指标上表现出最显著的改善,突出了这种方法改善患者整体预后的潜力。治疗组之间在表现上的显著差异表明,采用更全面、综合的方法治疗膝关节OA可能会带来更好的管理效果。