O'Hora Lee, O'Brien Kirsten, Tuffy John, Craig Agnella, Neville Noelle, Sugrue Kay, Keaveney Margaret, O'Brien Emma, Quinn Eimear, Egan Sean
The Health Information and Quality Authority (HIQA), Unit 1301, City Gate, Mahon, Cork, T12 Y2xt Cork, Ireland.
Eur J Radiol. 2025 Feb;183:111890. doi: 10.1016/j.ejrad.2024.111890. Epub 2024 Dec 18.
The purpose of this work was to establish national Irish diagnostic reference levels (DRLs) for a clinically representative and comprehensive list of clinical indications, anatomical regions, and common procedures for fluoroscopy and fluoroscopically guided interventions and compare these, where possible, to other DRLs established at a national level.
A list of clinical indications, anatomical regions and common procedures was established. A national database of service providers was used to identify all medical radiological facilities providing fluoroscopy and fluoroscopically guided intervention services. These facilities were issued with an online survey. National Pka DRLs were set as the 75th percentile of the distribution of median values obtained. A national median dose was also established which is the 50th percentile of the median doses provided by facilities for the same patients and conditions as the national DRL value. The broad categorisation of equipment type was also considered. Where statistically significant differences were found between different detector types, detector specific national DRLs were established (flat panel detector and image intensifier specific DRLs).
National Pka DRLs were established for 52 fluoroscopy and fluoroscopically guided intervention clinical indications, anatomical regions, and procedures. In addition, equipment specific (flat panel detector and image intensifier based systems) adult DRLs were established for the EVAR and lumbar puncture under fluoroscopy procedures. Paediatric DRLs were established for two fluoroscopy and fluoroscopically guided intervention clinical indications, anatomical regions, and procedures across various weight categories. Comparisons with other nationally set DRLs and other relevant literature suggest that Irish DRLs are typically lower than those established elsewhere.
This work provided a unique opportunity to establish national DRLs based on census data for a wide range of clinical indications, anatomical regions, and procedures across adult and paediatric fluoroscopy and fluoroscopically guided interventions. Where comparisons with other nationally established work was possible Irish values are largely below other DRLs.
本研究旨在为爱尔兰建立一套涵盖具有临床代表性且全面的透视及透视引导介入的临床指征、解剖区域和常见操作的国家诊断参考水平(DRLs),并在可能的情况下,将这些水平与其他国家制定的DRLs进行比较。
确定了临床指征、解剖区域和常见操作的清单。利用全国服务提供商数据库,识别出所有提供透视及透视引导介入服务的医学放射设施。向这些设施发放了在线调查问卷。将全国Pka DRLs设定为所获中位数分布的第75百分位数。还确定了全国中位数剂量,即设施针对与全国DRL值相同患者和情况所提供中位数剂量的第50百分位数。同时也考虑了设备类型的大致分类。当发现不同探测器类型之间存在统计学显著差异时,建立了特定探测器的国家DRLs(平板探测器和影像增强器特定DRLs)。
为52种透视及透视引导介入的临床指征、解剖区域和操作建立了国家Pka DRLs。此外,针对血管内腹主动脉瘤修复术(EVAR)和透视下腰椎穿刺操作,建立了特定设备(基于平板探测器和影像增强器的系统)的成人DRLs。针对不同体重类别的两种透视及透视引导介入的临床指征、解剖区域和操作,建立了儿科DRLs。与其他国家设定的DRLs及其他相关文献的比较表明,爱尔兰的DRLs通常低于其他地方制定的水平。
本研究提供了一个独特的机会,可基于普查数据为成人和儿科的广泛透视及透视引导介入的临床指征、解剖区域和操作建立国家DRLs。在与其他国家开展的工作进行比较时,爱尔兰的数值大多低于其他DRLs。