Phillips S, Friedman S B, Zebal B H
J Dev Behav Pediatr. 1985 Feb;6(1):15-21.
Three groups of residency programs were compared: 11 externally funded to provide mandatory behavioral training, seven not externally funded but providing mandatory training, and six controls not requiring training. At the beginning and end of 1980-1981, 569 residents (70%) completed questionnaires assessing attitudes regarding behavioral disorders, physical disorders, and "mixed" disorders (with physical and behavioral aspects). Behavioral knowledge was tested by 60 multiple-choice questions. Virtually all significant effects of program type occurred in the PL-2 year. For three attitudinal measures, "competence in management," "ability to advise parents," and "future relevance," only Funded residents demonstrated higher change scores for both behavioral and mixed disorders, relative to physical disorders; Funded and Not Funded residents were superior to Controls regarding behavioral disorders. For "knowledge of resources" and "facility interest," Not Funded change was superior to Control. Given higher Funded ratings initially, Not Funded ratings approximated Funded ratings by the end of the year. Regarding knowledge, Funded and Not Funded residents showed greater improvement than Controls. These data suggest that: changes in attitudes and knowledge are related to mandatory training; Funded programs generate the most consistent changes in both behavioral and "mixed" disorders; and the impact of training is most evident in the PL-2 year.
11个由外部资助以提供强制性行为培训的项目、7个未获外部资助但提供强制性培训的项目,以及6个不要求培训的对照项目。在1980 - 1981年开始和结束时,569名住院医师(70%)完成了问卷调查,评估他们对行为障碍、身体疾病和“混合”障碍(兼具身体和行为方面)的态度。行为知识通过60道多项选择题进行测试。项目类型的几乎所有显著影响都出现在PL - 2年。对于三项态度指标,即“管理能力”、“为家长提供建议的能力”和“未来相关性”,相对于身体疾病,只有获得资助的住院医师在行为障碍和混合障碍方面表现出更高的变化得分;在行为障碍方面,获得资助和未获得资助的住院医师均优于对照组。对于“资源知识”和“设施兴趣”,未获得资助组的变化优于对照组。鉴于最初获得资助组的评分较高,到年底时未获得资助组的评分接近获得资助组的评分。在知识方面,获得资助和未获得资助的住院医师比对照组有更大的进步。这些数据表明:态度和知识的变化与强制性培训有关;获得资助的项目在行为障碍和“混合”障碍方面产生的变化最为一致;培训的影响在PL - 2年最为明显。