Lv Yifan, Dong Xiaosheng, Sun Tingting, Jiang Shan, Gao Yue, Liang Jiaxin, Hu Songhan, Yu Haohan, Hou Xiao
People's Public Security University of China, Beijing, China.
Centre for Health Management and Policy Research, School of Public Health, Cheeloo College of Medicine, Shandong University, Jinan, China.
Sci Rep. 2024 Dec 28;14(1):30939. doi: 10.1038/s41598-024-81538-0.
Chronic sedentary behavior can have a negative impact on the executive function (EF) of young people. While physical activity (PA) has been shown to improve this phenomenon, the effects of different types of PA on EF vary. In this study, we compared the effects of moderate-intensity continuous training (MICT) (60-70% HRmax, 30 min), body weight training (BWT) (2 sets tabata, 20 min), and mind-body exercise (MBE) (2 sets Yang style shadowboxing, 20 min) on EF in 59 sedentary youth (n = 59, age = 20.36 ± 1.78, BMI = 24.91 ± 1.82, P>0.05) to identify the optimal dose of PA for improving EF. Metrics related to the EF task paradigm included stop signal, electroencephalogram (EEG), event-related potential (ERP), P300, N200, error-related negativity (ERN), and error positivity (Pe). error positivity (Pe), and β-wave in frontal lobe; training monitoring, including heart rate (HR), rating of perceived exertion (RPE), feeling scale (FS), and dual-mode model (DMM); load assessment, including Edward's TRIMP (TRIMP) and session-RPE (s-RPE). The study results indicate that BWT significantly improved accuracy in terms of EF (F = 16.84, P = 0.0381) and was comparable to MICT in terms of shortening reaction time (F = 58.03, P = 0.0217; F = 75.49, P = 0.0178). Regarding ERP, BWT reduced the amplitude values of N200 compared to ERN (F = 44.35, P = 0.0351; F = 48.68, P = 0.0317), increased P300 compared to Pe (F = 97.72, P<0.01; F = 29.56, P = 0.0189), and shortened P300 latency (F = 1.84, P = 0.0406). In contrast, MICT was only effective for P300 with Pe (F = 66.59, P = 0.0194; F = 21.04, P = 0.0342) and shortened N200 latency (F = 27.29, P = 0.0411). The increase in total amplitude and β-oscillation in terms of EEG was proportional to the exercise intensity, with the difference between MICT and BWT being present at 5-20 Hz, and MBE at 10-15 Hz. Regarding training load, the order of HR, RPE, TRIMP, and s-RPE was BWT > MICT > MBE (F = 202.69; F = 114.69; F = 114.69; P = 0.0342). The latency of N200 was also shortened (F = 27.29, P = 0.0411). The results showed that PA improves EF in sedentary youth, although BWT works best, it leads to a decrease in motor perception. Initially, MICT was scheduled alongside MBE and later replaced with BWT. This may help establish an exercise habit while improving EF.
长期久坐行为会对年轻人的执行功能(EF)产生负面影响。虽然体育活动(PA)已被证明可改善这一现象,但不同类型的体育活动对执行功能的影响各不相同。在本研究中,我们比较了中等强度持续训练(MICT)(60 - 70%心率储备,30分钟)、体重训练(BWT)(2组塔巴塔训练,20分钟)和身心锻炼(MBE)(2组杨氏太极拳,20分钟)对59名久坐不动的年轻人(n = 59,年龄 = 20.36 ± 1.78,体重指数 = 24.91 ± 1.82,P>0.05)执行功能的影响,以确定改善执行功能的最佳体育活动剂量。与执行功能任务范式相关的指标包括停止信号、脑电图(EEG)、事件相关电位(ERP)、P300、N200、错误相关负波(ERN)和错误正波(Pe)。额叶中的错误正波(Pe)和β波;训练监测,包括心率(HR)、主观用力程度分级(RPE)、感觉量表(FS)和双模式模型(DMM);负荷评估,包括爱德华氏训练负荷积分(TRIMP)和单次训练主观用力程度(s - RPE)。研究结果表明,体重训练在执行功能方面显著提高了准确性(F = 16.84,P = 0.0381),在缩短反应时间方面与中等强度持续训练相当(F = 58.03,P = 0.0217;F = 75.49,P = 0.0178)。关于事件相关电位,与错误相关负波相比,体重训练降低了N200的幅值(F = 44.35,P = 0.0351;F = 48.68,P = 0.0317),与错误正波相比增加了P300(F = 97.72,P<0.01;F = 29.56,P = 0.0189),并缩短了P300潜伏期(F = 1.84,P = 0.0406)。相比之下,中等强度持续训练仅对P300与错误正波有影响(F = 66.59,P = 0.0194;F = 21.04,P = 0.0342),并缩短了N200潜伏期(F = 27.29,P = 0.0411)。脑电图总幅值和β振荡的增加与运动强度成正比,中等强度持续训练和体重训练之间的差异出现在5 - 20赫兹,身心锻炼出现在10 - 15赫兹。关于训练负荷,心率、主观用力程度分级、训练负荷积分和单次训练主观用力程度的顺序为体重训练>中等强度持续训练>身心锻炼(F = 202.69;F = 114.69;F = 114.69;P = 0.0342)。N200的潜伏期也缩短了(F = 27.29,P = 0.0411)。结果表明,体育活动可改善久坐不动年轻人的执行功能,虽然体重训练效果最佳,但会导致运动感知下降。最初,中等强度持续训练与身心锻炼同时安排,后来被体重训练取代。这可能有助于在改善执行功能的同时建立运动习惯。